| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Copernicus | Basque Witch Trials | Würzburg Trials | The Basque Witch Trials were less brutal and had more skepticism and legal oversight, making them a slightly better alternative in the grim context of witch trials. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Basque Witch Trials | Vaudois Witch Trials | Well ya know, Norm, the Basque Witch Trials had a broader impact in history, putting the spotlight on the Pyrenean region and its unique culture, making 'em quite the fascinating topic for the ol' trivia night. |
 | George Washington Carver | Basque Witch Trials | Bamberg Trials | Both were dark times, but the Basque Witch Trials ended with some enlightenment and restraint, unlike the rampant chaos in Bamberg. |
 | Galileo | Basque Witch Trials | Würzburg Trials | Basque Witch Trials weren't as deadly as the intense Würzburg madness, so I'd go with the lesser chaos, amigo. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Basque Witch Trials | Fulda Witch Trials | The Basque Witch Trials were more about superstition and ignorance, but at least they weren't as gruesomely brutal and widespread as the Fulda ones. |
 | Andy Weir | Basque Witch Trials | Fulda Witch Trials | The Basque Witch Trials were less deadly and more about cultural conflicts than mass hysteria, which makes them slightly less grim in the history of witch trials. |
| Cliff Clavin | Basque Witch Trials | Fulda Witch Trials | Well ya see, the Basque Witch Trials were bigger and more complex, like a trivia question with extra parts, while the Fulda ones were a bit on the smaller scale, so Basque wins for being the more intricate doozy. |
| Copernicus | Basque Witch Trials | Trier Witch Trials | The Basque Witch Trials were less deadly and had a more skeptical judge, which kinda makes them the lesser of two evils. |
 | Charles Babbage | Basque Witch Trials | Salem Witch Trials | The Basque Witch Trials get the nod because their scale and duration were much larger, showcasing the era's intense superstitions more vividly. |
 | Klaus Teuber | Basque Witch Trials | Bamberg Trials | The Basque Witch Trials had a larger cultural impact and a more significant influence on the collective memory in the region, making them more historically intriguing. |
| Charles Babbage | Basque Witch Trials | Fulda Witch Trials | The Basque Witch Trials were less deadly and had more focus on skepticism and rationality, making them slightly less horrific than the Fulda Witch Trials. |
 | George Orwell | Basque Witch Trials | Torsåker Witch Trials | The Basque Witch Trials were marked by a level of skepticism and rationality more in line with reason, as Inquisitor Salazar questioned the validity of the accusations, whereas the Torsåker Witch Trials were a grim affair with mass executions driven by paranoia. |
 | Alan Mathison Turing | Basque Witch Trials | Trier Witch Trials | Basque Witch Trials had some cool folks like Alonso de Salazar Frías throwing shade on witch hunts, making it a tad more chill than the crazy burn-fest in Trier. |
| Galileo | Basque Witch Trials | Bamberg Trials | The Basque Witch Trials were less brutal and had a stronger focus on legal reform, so they get my vote for being the lesser of two evils, dude. |
 | Louis Pasteur | Basque Witch Trials | Würzburg Trials | The Basque Witch Trials showed more restraint and skepticism compared to the widespread panic and mass executions of the Würzburg Trials. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Basque Witch Trials | Salem Witch Trials | Basque Witch Trials were a bigger historical drama with way more going on in terms of legal shenanigans and crazy confessions, so they take the cake for sheer complexity and intrigue! |
 | Steve Wozniak | Basque Witch Trials | Salem Witch Trials | The Basque Witch Trials, despite their grim nature, were part of a broader historical context with more documentation and judicial reforms, giving us valuable insights into the era's cultural and legal systems. |
 | Doogie Howser | Basque Witch Trials | Salem Witch Trials | The Basque Witch Trials were way more chill, with fewer executions and a more skeptical vibe from the authorities. |
 | Cicero | Vaudois Witch Trials | Basque Witch Trials | The Vaudois Witch Trials, being some of the earliest in European history, highlight the profound human folly of witch hunts, making them a grim reminder of how fear can lead to injustice. |
 | Larry Page | Basque Witch Trials | Bamberg Trials | The Basque Witch Trials get the nod for being more culturally complex and emblematic of localized beliefs, unlike the more politically charged Bamberg Trials. |