| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Pliny the Elder | Red Dead Redemption | The Witcher 3 | I love immersing myself in the gritty, cinematic world of Red Dead Redemption, where the cowboys and outlaws feel more like living legends in a sweeping, wild west saga. |
 | Klaus Teuber | The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild | Red Dead Redemption | As a game designer, I admire the open-world creativity and innovative mechanics in Breath of the Wild that give players immense freedom, much like the strategic possibilities I aim for in my board games. |
 | Pliny the Elder | Red Dead Redemption | Celeste | As Pliny the Elder, I would marvel at the vast open-world splendor and historical adventure in Red Dead Redemption, reminiscent of epic tales from our own history. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | Red Dead Redemption | Dark Souls | Red Dead Redemption's storytelling and open-world exploration echo the human condition in ways that Dark Souls' cryptic mystique simply doesn't saddle up to. |
 | Data | God of War | Red Dead Redemption | God of War's epic storyline and mythological depth just slaps harder for those who crave a cinematic experience. |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Red Dead Redemption | Hollow Knight | Given my frontier spirit and appreciation for open-world adventures, Red Dead Redemption is my kind of game, filled with the rugged landscapes and moral quandaries Iām known for. |
 | Louis Pasteur | The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild | Red Dead Redemption | As a scientist fascinated by exploration and discovery, Breath of the Wild's vast, open world and inventive gameplay resonate more with my thirst for curiosity and experimentation. |
 | Steve Wozniak | Hades | Red Dead Redemption | Hades wins for its innovative gameplay loop and rogue-like elements that keep the techie in me engaged with its dynamic storytelling and crisp mechanics. |
 | Stephen Hawking | Red Dead Redemption | Super Mario Odyssey | Red Dead Redemption offers a rich narrative and immersive world that speaks to the complexity and beauty of the universe, much like the intricate theories of physics. |
 | George Washington Carver | Hades | Red Dead Redemption | Hades has that tight roguelike action and quick replayability that hooks me like a research project, while Red Dead's more of a sprawling, slow-burn adventure. |
 | Charles Darwin | Red Dead Redemption | God of War | As a man fascinated by evolution and the wild, Red Dead Redemption's open-world exploration and authentic frontier atmosphere appeals to my adventurous spirit. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | Celeste | Red Dead Redemption | Celeste triumphs because itās a poignant narrative about mental health and personal growth, wrapped in a challenging yet rewarding platformer experience, which aligns with my belief in the exploration of the human condition. |
 | Grace Hopper | The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild | Red Dead Redemption | The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild just takes the cake with its open-world magic and endless sense of adventure that tickles my nerdy soul. |
 | Claude Shannon | Dark Souls | Red Dead Redemption | Dark Souls' punishing difficulty and intricate lore deliver a uniquely rewarding challenge for gamers who crave depth and perseverance. |
 | Socrates | Red Dead Redemption | Hollow Knight | Red Dead Redemption takes the crown 'cause its vast, immersive world and gripping storyline ride circles around most games out there. |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Stardew Valley | Red Dead Redemption | As a man of humble roots and a fondness for farming and community, Stardew Valley's peaceful charm and focus on building relationships resonate deeply with my spirit. |
 | Linus Torvalds | Celeste | Red Dead Redemption | Celeste nails that challenging yet rewarding gameplay, kinda like perfecting kernel code, where every move counts. |
 | Charles Darwin | The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild | Red Dead Redemption | Breath of the Wild redefined open-world gaming with its sense of freedom and exploration that mirrors the wonder of exploring nature itself. |