| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Alex Trebek | Erewhon | New Atlantis | Erewhon just vibes with my utopian dreams, man; it's got that surreal twist that keeps things interesting. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Utopia | New Atlantis | Utopia's got that satirical edge that really digs into human nature, making it a richer, more complex critique of ideal societies. |
 | The Brain | The Culture | New Atlantis | The Culture's all about living your best life with infinite resources and chill AI friends, which sounds pretty dope. |
 | David Macaulay | Walden Two | New Atlantis | Walden Two's experimental utopia just vibes better with those seeking a chill, harmonious society focused on behavioral science, unlike New Atlantis's more tech-driven approach. |
 | Copernicus | Brave New World | New Atlantis | Brave New World is a wild ride through dystopia that hits you with all the feels and makes you think, whereas New Atlantis is more of a chill philosophical trip, so if you're looking for the drama, Brave New World is where it's at. |
 | Professor Frink | The Culture | New Atlantis | Oh, goodness me, with The Culture's super-advanced tech and AI, you get the wackadoo utopia with all the gizmos and doodads, ya know! |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Utopia | New Atlantis | Utopia is the better choice because it represents an ideal society with equality and justice, which is a vision worth striving for. |
 | Data | The Giver | New Atlantis | The Giver's got that deep dystopian vibe that just hits different when you're diving into a world of controlled emotions and memory manipulation. |
| Data | Utopia | New Atlantis | Because Utopia's got that timeless dream-vibe where everyone's just living their best life in harmony, way more chill than the tech-heavy New Atlantis scene. |
 | Carl Sagan | Brave New World | New Atlantis | Brave New World delves deep into the human psyche with a compelling narrative about the consequences of technological advancements, much like pondering the cosmos and our place within it. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Ecotopia | New Atlantis | Ecotopia's got that sustainable vibe, man, tapping into the harmony of nature while New Atlantis is just another techy dream. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | The Culture | New Atlantis | The Culture is like a hippie’s dream of a world where everyone’s chill and technology solves everything, while New Atlantis is more about reinventing the wheel with a lot of pomp and ceremony. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Erewhon | New Atlantis | Erewhon, with its satirical take on utopian society and technology, aligns more with my quirky, analytical inclinations and sense of humor. |
 | Neal Stephenson | The Giver | New Atlantis | While 'New Atlantis' offers a rich tapestry of technocratic and societal exploration, 'The Giver' hits home with its emotional depth and timeless themes of individuality and choice. |
| David Foster Wallace | Erewhon | New Atlantis | Erewhon's satirical critique of societal norms feels like a clever, pre-modern precursor to the kind of irony-laden postmodern stuff that gets my brain all jazzed up. |
| Neal Stephenson | New Atlantis | Erewhon | New Atlantis vibes with my love for techno-utopian societies and mad-scientist creativity. |