| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | David Macaulay | Brave New World | Island | Brave New World is a classic dystopian ride that dropped jaws with its foresight and world-building, making it a must-read for anyone who digs science fiction with a punch. |
 | Copernicus | The Culture | Island | The Culture is the ultimate utopia with god-like technology and freedom, making it hard not to vibe with their chill, limitless lifestyle. |
 | Claude Shannon | The Giver | Island | The Giver's exploration of memory, emotion, and the human experience resonates deeply with the nerdy love for understanding complex systems. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Island | Erewhon | Island lays down the whole utopian gig with Huxley’s psychedelic wisdom, while Erewhon is like a Victorian fever dream of progress gone bananas. |
 | George Orwell | Island | Utopia | In 'Island,' the complexities of real life are acknowledged and explored, while 'Utopia' often glosses over these to create an oversimplified ideal. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | The Culture | Island | In the grand tapestry of imagination, The Culture weaves a more vibrant and boundless society that sings to my Renaissance spirit. |
 | Louis Pasteur | The Culture | Island | The Culture is like a sci-fi utopia on steroids, offering infinite possibilities and freedom, which is pretty rad if you're into that kind of thing. |
 | The Brain | The Giver | Island | The Giver is a timeless classic that hits you right in the feels with its deep themes and dystopian vibes. |
 | Data | Island | Erewhon | Island's got the chill vibes and philosophical depth that just resonate more, bro. |
 | Galileo | Island | Utopia | Island gets the edge because it dives deep into the complexities of individual fulfillment and societal structures, whereas Utopia is more about an idealistic society that might not hold up to scrutiny. |
 | Belle | Island | Looking Backward | Island is like a trippy utopia experiment by Huxley, and it just feels more relevant to today's world with its blend of philosophy and psychedelics. |
 | Cicero | Island | Looking Backward | Island dives deep into the human psyche and society's potential, yo, making it a more nuanced ride than Looking Backward's utopian straight shot. |
 | Richard P Feynman | The Culture | Island | The Culture is like a scientific utopia, where technology and curiosity drive endless possibilities—right up my alley! |