| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | David Macaulay | Vanishing Hitchhiker | Bigfoot Sighting | Vanishing Hitchhiker wins because itโs a creepy campfire classic that keeps folks looking over their shoulder more than any fuzzy Bigfoot tale. |
 | Charles Darwin | Vanishing Hitchhiker | Chupacabra Attacks | I gotta go with the Vanishing Hitchhiker, 'cause nothing beats a good ghost story when you're cruising down a lonely road at night. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Vanishing Hitchhiker | Killer Clown | The Vanishing Hitchhiker is classic and mysterious, while Killer Clown is overdone and just plain creepy! |
 | Marie Curie | Vanishing Hitchhiker | Slenderman Sightings | As a scientist, I value tales that have been around longer, and the Vanishing Hitchhiker is a classic urban legend, showcasing cultural storytelling at its finest. |
 | The Brain | Vanishing Hitchhiker | Bigfoot Sighting | Vanishing Hitchhiker stories hit harder 'cause they spook you with a ghostly twist that sticks in your brain longer than a fuzzy Bigfoot photo. |
 | Socrates | Vanishing Hitchhiker | Crop Circles | Vanishing Hitchhiker is way spookier and taps into the good ol' campfire ghost story vibes we all love. |
 | Stephen Hawking | Vanishing Hitchhiker | Chupacabra Attacks | Vanishing Hitchhiker tales tap into the timeless, creepy fear of picking up strangers and ghostly encounters on lonely roads, while Chupacabra Attacks are just a bit too niche and creature-feature for my taste. |
 | Antoine Lavoisier | Vanishing Hitchhiker | Bigfoot Sighting | The Vanishing Hitchhiker just has that classic eerie ghost story vibe that hits you right in the spine. |
 | Belle | Vanishing Hitchhiker | Hookman Killer | Vanishing Hitchhiker's got that mysterious ghostly vibe that just sticks with you, unlike the Hookman's predictable slasher style. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Vanishing Hitchhiker | Mothman Prophecies | Well, ya know, the Vanishing Hitchhiker is a classic urban legend that's been around forever, so it's like the Norm of folkloreโeverybody knows it and it always gets a reaction. |
 | Doc Brown | Vanishing Hitchhiker | Hookman Killer | The Vanishing Hitchhiker wins 'cause it's that classic creepy tale where you're left wondering if you just had a ghost in your backseat, giving you chills every time you pick up a stranger. |
 | Alex Trebek | Vanishing Hitchhiker | Slenderman Sightings | The Vanishing Hitchhiker is an OG urban legend that keeps you guessing and gives you chills without needing a digital age reboot. |
| Cliff Clavin | Vanishing Hitchhiker | Crop Circles | Well, ya know, the vanishing hitchhiker's got that classic urban legend flair that's been spookin' folks since the dawn of car culture, while crop circles tend to just leave ya wonderin' if some bored lads were havin' a lark in the fields. |
 | Data | Vanishing Hitchhiker | Chupacabra Attacks | Vanishing Hitchhiker stories are classic urban legends that have spooked people for generations, while Chupacabra is more niche and region-specific. |
 | George Washington Carver | Loch Ness Monster | Vanishing Hitchhiker | I'm all about those natural mysteries, and Nessie's got that earthly, scientific intrigue that just hooks ya in! |
 | Nikola Tesla | Vanishing Hitchhiker | Killer Clown | As a man of science and mystery, the Vanishing Hitchhiker wins for its eerie blend of the supernatural and the unexplainedโtruly electrifying! |