| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Doogie Howser | Mothman Prophecies | Chupacabra Attacks | Mothman Prophecies gets the edge because its eerie mix of folklore and suspense just keeps you on your toes more than Chupacabra sightings. |
 | Buckminster Fuller | Mothman Prophecies | Chupacabra Attacks | Mothman Prophecies offers a more intriguing exploration of human experiences and perceptions, tapping into the wonder and mystery that fuels our imagination and innovation. |
 | Charles Darwin | Vanishing Hitchhiker | Chupacabra Attacks | I gotta go with the Vanishing Hitchhiker, 'cause nothing beats a good ghost story when you're cruising down a lonely road at night. |
| Buckminster Fuller | Chupacabra Attacks | Bloody Mary | Chupacabra attacks are the wild chaos of cryptid tales, far outshining a simple cocktail spook story any day. |
 | Stephen Hawking | Vanishing Hitchhiker | Chupacabra Attacks | Vanishing Hitchhiker tales tap into the timeless, creepy fear of picking up strangers and ghostly encounters on lonely roads, while Chupacabra Attacks are just a bit too niche and creature-feature for my taste. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | Loch Ness Monster | Chupacabra Attacks | The Loch Ness Monster, with its mysterious allure and ancient charm, weaves a yarn that taps into our deepest love for the mythical and the unknown. |
 | Charles Babbage | Chupacabra Attacks | Killer Clown | Chupacabra Attacks are just way more spine-chilling because they tap into that primal fear of unknown beasts lurking in the shadows. |
 | Andy Weir | Mothman Prophecies | Chupacabra Attacks | Mothman Prophecies just has that extra layer of eerie mystique that makes it a classic in urban legend lore. |
 | Marie Curie | Bloody Mary | Chupacabra Attacks | As a scientist, I gotta say, the Bloody Mary myth has a more interesting psychological aspect about human perception and fear, while Chupacabra attacks are just too far-fetched for my taste. |
| Kurt Vonnegut | Chupacabra Attacks | Bloody Mary | Because a Chupacabra Attack's got that wild, unpredictable chaos that makes life feel like a Vonnegut novel, while Bloody Mary just hangs around in mirrors like a sad party trick. |
 | Greg Brockman | Mothman Prophecies | Chupacabra Attacks | Mothman Prophecies is more intriguing with its blend of eerie folklore and real-life events, making it a classic urban legend thriller. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Loch Ness Monster | Chupacabra Attacks | The Loch Ness Monster's got that mysterious, ancient charm that just tickles the imagination of a scientist like me. |
| Andy Weir | Chupacabra Attacks | Killer Clown | Chupacabra Attacks are way cooler because who doesn't love a creepy cryptid story to spice up your nightmares? |
 | Data | Vanishing Hitchhiker | Chupacabra Attacks | Vanishing Hitchhiker stories are classic urban legends that have spooked people for generations, while Chupacabra is more niche and region-specific. |
| Richard P Feynman | Slenderman Sightings | Chupacabra Attacks | Slenderman Sightings are more intriguing because the internet made him famous, blending fiction with reality in a way that's like a social experiment in storytelling. |
| Charles Babbage | Chupacabra Attacks | Slenderman Sightings | Chupacabra Attacks edge it out because they're rooted in old school folklore, adding a dash of cultural spice that Slenderman just can't compete with, being more of a modern internet meme. |
 | Albert Einstein | Loch Ness Monster | Chupacabra Attacks | Given the Loch Ness Monster's legendary status and its charming mystery over the years, it trumps the Chupacabra's spooky, goat-sucking tales. |