| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Charles Babbage | Bigfoot Sighting | Bloody Mary | Bigfoot sightings give you a chance to ponder the mysteries of nature, which is way cooler than just scaring yourself in a bathroom mirror. |
 | Albert Einstein | Loch Ness Monster | Bloody Mary | The Loch Ness Monster is a classic cryptid with a mysterious allure that captivates the imagination just like a good, unsolved scientific puzzle! |
 | Buckminster Fuller | Mothman Prophecies | Bloody Mary | Mothman Prophecies is a wild trip into the unknown, blending mystery and eerie encounters, which vibes more with my love for exploring the edges of human perception and phenomena. |
 | Grace Hopper | Loch Ness Monster | Bloody Mary | The Loch Ness Monster's got that mysterious allure and cryptid cred that Bloody Mary just can't match with her mirror-game spooks. |
 | Buckminster Fuller | Chupacabra Attacks | Bloody Mary | Chupacabra attacks are the wild chaos of cryptid tales, far outshining a simple cocktail spook story any day. |
 | Cicero | Loch Ness Monster | Bloody Mary | Loch Ness Monster's got that classic mystery vibe, a legendary creature lurking in the deep, while Bloody Mary is more like a party trick for scaring kids in bathrooms. |
 | Doc Brown | Bloody Mary | Killer Clown | Bloody Mary is the OG ghost story, popping up in mirrors and scaring the living daylights outta folks, just like me showing up with my DeLorean! |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Bloody Mary | Slenderman Sightings | Listen, Bloody Mary is an OG in the horror folklore game, coming at ya with mirrors and creepy chants, that's classic stuff right there. |
 | Doogie Howser | Bigfoot Sighting | Bloody Mary | Bigfoot Sighting wins 'cause it's got that cool, mysterious outdoorsy vibe and leaves you with a fun story to tell around the campfire! |
 | Charles Babbage | Bloody Mary | Hookman Killer | Bloody Mary is way creepier 'cause she pops up in your mirror when you least expect it, while Hookman Killer's just hangin' around with a hook. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Mothman Prophecies | Bloody Mary | Mothman Prophecies spooks you with mysterious vibes and chilling suspense, while Bloody Mary mostly just makes you uneasy in a dark bathroom. |
 | Marie Curie | Bloody Mary | Chupacabra Attacks | As a scientist, I gotta say, the Bloody Mary myth has a more interesting psychological aspect about human perception and fear, while Chupacabra attacks are just too far-fetched for my taste. |
 | Linus Torvalds | Loch Ness Monster | Bloody Mary | The Loch Ness Monster is a legendary mythical creature like Linux, while Bloody Mary is just a scary story you tell at sleepovers. |
 | Marie Curie | Bigfoot Sighting | Bloody Mary | Bigfoot Sighting is more intriguing because it taps into the scientific curiosity of discovering an unknown creature. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | Chupacabra Attacks | Bloody Mary | Because a Chupacabra Attack's got that wild, unpredictable chaos that makes life feel like a Vonnegut novel, while Bloody Mary just hangs around in mirrors like a sad party trick. |
 | Pliny the Elder | Bloody Mary | Hookman Killer | Bloody Mary's got that timeless, ghostly allure that keeps folks daring each other to chant her name, while the Hookman Killer is more of a campfire tale that fades away after the s'mores are gone. |
 | Carl Sagan | Loch Ness Monster | Bloody Mary | As a scientist, the allure of the Loch Ness Monster lies in the possibility of discovering a cryptid rooted in paleontological mysteries. |
 | Andy Weir | Mothman Prophecies | Bloody Mary | Mothman Prophecies blends mystery and the supernatural with a hint of science geekiness that just hits the right spot for the curious mind. |
 | Ada Lovelace | Killer Clown | Bloody Mary | Killer Clown's got that unpredictable mischief vibe, and who doesn't love a wild card in the horror mix? |
 | Professor Frink | Killer Clown | Bloody Mary | Well, if we're talking about sheer unpredictability and the element of surprise, a Killer Clown takes the cake, or the balloon, because they're just so dynamic, and whoa, that unpredictability factor, it really gets ya, y'know! |
 | Archimedes | Loch Ness Monster | Bloody Mary | The Loch Ness Monster is legendary, stirring up curiosity and wonder; she's like the mysterious introvert everyone's secretly fascinated by. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Slenderman Sightings | Bloody Mary | Slenderman Sightings have a deeper internet culture history and spurred creative storytelling and digital folklore, which is fascinating from a sociocultural perspective. |