| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Cabbage Soup Diet | Breatharian Diet | Cabbage Soup Diet, 'cause at least you're eating something rather than just pretending food is optional. |
 | John von Neumann | Cabbage Soup Diet | Grapefruit Diet | Cabbage Soup Diet wins because at least you get to eat a variety of veggies, and variety is the spice of life, even if it's just cabbage-spiced! |
 | Richard P Feynman | Apple Cider Vinegar Diet | Cabbage Soup Diet | Apple Cider Vinegar Diet wins because it's more sustainable and doesn't involve eating soup like you're at some endless cabbage carnival. |
 | Larry Page | Cabbage Soup Diet | Breatharian Diet | The Cabbage Soup Diet, while not perfect, at least provides some nutrients, whereas the Breatharian Diet is just a one-way ticket to a health crisis. |
 | Alex Trebek | Cabbage Soup Diet | Werewolf Diet | The Cabbage Soup Diet might have you eating like a rabbit, but at least it doesn't rely on lunar phases that leave you howling for more food. |
 | Greg Brockman | Cabbage Soup Diet | Tapeworm Diet | The Cabbage Soup Diet might be kinda bland, but at least it doesn't involve swallowing a parasite for weight loss, which is downright gnarly. |
 | The Brain | Cabbage Soup Diet | Baby Food Diet | Cabbage Soup Diet wins because, let's be real, an adult eating baby food just ain't gonna cut it for any serious hunger pangs. |
 | Andy Weir | Cabbage Soup Diet | Cookie Diet | Look, at least with the Cabbage Soup Diet you get some real food and fiber, instead of just cookies pretending to be a diet. |
 | Galileo | Cabbage Soup Diet | Breatharian Diet | The Cabbage Soup Diet at least involves eating actual food, while the Breatharian Diet is dangerously based on the false belief that you can survive without it. |
 | Nerds | Cabbage Soup Diet | Sleeping Beauty Diet | Cabbage Soup Diet wins because starving while pretending to be a Disney princess ain't exactly a sustainable weight loss plan, ya know? |
 | Charles Darwin | Cabbage Soup Diet | Werewolf Diet | Both diets have their pitfalls, but the Cabbage Soup Diet at least gives you some nutrients beyond just lunar cycles and starvation. |
 | Grace Hopper | Cabbage Soup Diet | Tapeworm Diet | Cabbage Soup Diet may be boring, but at least you're not inviting parasites into your body, which is just plain gross and risky. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Cabbage Soup Diet | Cotton Ball Diet | Both are kinda whack, but at least the Cabbage Soup Diet involves actual food and not chomping on fluff. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Cabbage Soup Diet | Cookie Diet | Well ya know, the Cabbage Soup Diet might not be as tasty as cookies, but it's like my Ma always said: it's a whole lot better for ya in the long run if ya wanna keep the ol' ticker ticking. |
 | Doc Brown | Cabbage Soup Diet | Breatharian Diet | The Cabbage Soup Diet might be a bit bland, but at least it's got actual food, unlike the Breatharian Diet which is all smoke and mirrors! |
 | Charles Babbage | Cabbage Soup Diet | Tapeworm Diet | The Cabbage Soup Diet is the lesser evil because eating a tapeworm sounds like a horror movie plot, not a weight loss plan. |
 | Antoine Lavoisier | Cabbage Soup Diet | Cookie Diet | Cabbage Soup Diet's got that homemade vibe and it's packed with veggies, while Cookie Diet sounds like a sugar rush waiting to crash. |