| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Carl Sagan | Wow! Signal | Nazca Lines | The Wow! Signal is like a cosmic mystery call that keeps us wondering if we're not alone, while the Nazca Lines are more like ancient Earthly art, so the cosmic wins for me! |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | Dark Matter | Wow! Signal | Dark Matter wins because it’s the universe’s secret sauce, making up most of what’s out there, even if it’s elusive and a bit like a cosmic prank. |
 | Socrates | Dark Matter | Wow! Signal | Dark Matter is like the universe's secret sauce, holding galaxies together, while the Wow! Signal is just a cosmic butt-dial with no follow-up. |
| Socrates | Wow! Signal | Taos Hum | The Wow! Signal is like finding a golden ticket in the cosmic chocolate bar, a true cosmic mystery, while the Taos Hum is more like an annoying fly you just can't swat. |
 | Guido van Rossum | Nazca Lines | Wow! Signal | The Nazca Lines are an ancient, enigmatic art form that showcases human creativity and culture, which I find fascinating and enduring. |
 | Copernicus | Wow! Signal | Bermuda Triangle | The Wow! Signal is a mind-blowing mystery from the cosmos that's got the nerd in me buzzing with excitement about potential alien contact! |
 | Belle | Wow! Signal | Jack the Ripper | Dude, the Wow! Signal is like cosmic mystery at its finest—potential alien contact trumps a grisly murder case any day. |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | Wow! Signal | Taos Hum | The Wow! Signal is like the holy grail of 'what the heck was that?' in space signals, while the Taos Hum is just one of those weird things that's probably a mundane earth sound. |
 | Nikola Tesla | Dark Matter | Wow! Signal | Dark Matter is like the universe's secret sauce, shaping galaxies while playing hard to get, and that's just electrifyingly mysterious! |
 | Alex Trebek | Stonehenge | Wow! Signal | Stonehenge is like a timeless rock concert that keeps the mystery alive, while the Wow! Signal is a one-hit wonder. |
 | Marie Curie | Wow! Signal | Taos Hum | The Wow! Signal is like a cosmic mystery note, possibly from extraterrestrials, while the Taos Hum is just an annoying sound with no clear origin. |
 | Data | Nazca Lines | Wow! Signal | The Nazca Lines are a mind-blowing blend of art and astronomy etched into the earth, still sparking wonder after centuries, while the Wow! Signal was a one-off cosmic mystery that left us hanging. |
| Marie Curie | Wow! Signal | Nazca Lines | As a scientist, Wow! Signal is way cooler because it's a cosmic mystery that could hint at extraterrestrial life, while the Nazca Lines are impressive but mostly archaeological art. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Wow! Signal | Taos Hum | The Wow! Signal is like the ultimate space mystery that gets every stargazer's heart racing, while the Taos Hum is more of an earthly annoyance that leaves folks scratching their heads. |
 | Alan Mathison Turing | Voynich Manuscript | Wow! Signal | The Voynich Manuscript is like a cryptic puzzle wrapped in mystery, and who doesn't love a good intellectual challenge? |
| Lonnie Johnson | Wow! Signal | Bermuda Triangle | The Wow! Signal is like the ultimate cosmic mystery call that keeps us nerds dreaming of extraterrestrial life, while the Bermuda Triangle feels more like an overhyped spot on the vacation map. |
 | John von Neumann | Wow! Signal | Voynich Manuscript | The Wow! Signal is like a cosmic 'Hello!' while the Voynich Manuscript is just unreadable scribbles. |
 | Antoine Lavoisier | Wow! Signal | Jack the Ripper | The Wow! Signal is a cosmic mystery that sparks imagination and wonder, unlike Jack the Ripper's reign of terror which only brings horror and despair. |
 | Archimedes | Wow! Signal | Jack the Ripper | Wow! Signal is like the ultimate cosmic mystery, man, because it's potential alien contact, while Jack the Ripper's just a creepy old murder case. |