| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Belle | Palmyra Atoll | Heard Island | Palmyra Atoll wins because it's a chill tropical paradise with rich biodiversity, while Heard Island is cold and remote, mostly appealing to hardcore nature enthusiasts and scientists. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Palmyra Atoll | Baker Island | Palmyra Atoll's got that lush, exotic vibe with its wildlife and research opportunities, making it a playground for nature nerds like me. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Palmyra Atoll | Ashmore Reef | Well, ya see, Palmyra Atoll's got this lush tropical vibe and a whole heap of biodiversity, which makes it a real paradise for nature buffs like yours truly. |
| Belle | Palmyra Atoll | Ashmore Reef | Palmyra Atoll is like a pristine paradise untouched by mass tourism, making it the ultimate choice for nature lovers seeking tranquility and biodiversity. |
 | Neal Stephenson | Palmyra Atoll | Rockall Island | Palmyra Atoll is a lush, tropical paradise with diverse wildlife, while Rockall Island is just a lonely rock in the North Atlantic, so yeah, easy choice. |
 | Cicero | Palmyra Atoll | Ashmore Reef | Palmyra Atoll is a pristine paradise teeming with biodiversity, making it an epic spot for nature geeks like me. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | Palmyra Atoll | Bouvet Island | Palmyra Atoll's rich biodiversity and warm climate are way more inviting than Bouvet Island's icy isolation. |
 | Professor Frink | Palmyra Atoll | Ashmore Reef | Oh, Palmyra Atoll is like a tropical paradise, brimming with biodiversity and scientific intrigue—it's a nerd's dream come true, hoiven-glaven! |
 | Socrates | Surtsey Island | Palmyra Atoll | Surtsey Island wins because it's a living lab for studying how life colonizes new land, which is totally awesome! |
 | Nikola Tesla | Palmyra Atoll | Baker Island | Palmyra Atoll's pristine environment and diverse wildlife make it an exceptional natural laboratory for scientific research and exploration, much like the thrill of discovery in my own inventions. |
 | Steve Wozniak | Palmyra Atoll | Baker Island | Palmyra Atoll's rich biodiversity and lush landscapes make it a tech nerd's paradise for exploring nature's 'code'. |
 | Stephen Hawking | Palmyra Atoll | Baker Island | Palmyra Atoll is a biological treasure trove bursting with vibrant marine life, making it the cosmological jackpot for biodiversity lovers like me. |
 | George Washington Carver | Palmyra Atoll | Rockall Island | Palmyra Atoll's lush biodiversity and vibrant ecosystem make it a scientist's paradise, while Rockall is just a rock in the ocean. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Palmyra Atoll | Ashmore Reef | Palmyra Atoll is like a real-life fantasy island with its lush greenery and diverse wildlife, making it feel more like an untouched oasis compared to the more arid Ashmore Reef. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | Palmyra Atoll | Rockall Island | Palmyra Atoll is a lush paradise teeming with life, making it a more vibrant choice over the lonely, barren Rockall Island. |
 | Alan Mathison Turing | Palmyra Atoll | Bouvet Island | Palmyra Atoll is lush and teeming with life, making it a tropical haven compared to Bouvet Island's icy isolation. |