| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Neal Stephenson | Baker Island | Rockall Island | Baker Island's closer tie to human history and accessibility makes it the nerd's choice over the desolate speck of Rockall. |
 | Cicero | Aldabra Atoll | Baker Island | Aldabra Atoll is like a wild, untouched paradise with mad biodiversity, while Baker Island is just a tiny, deserted speck with a cool history but not much else going on. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Baker Island | Clipperton Island | Baker Island wins because it’s got a fascinating history with aviation and science expeditions, resonating with my curiosity and love for exploration. |
| Richard P Feynman | Palmyra Atoll | Baker Island | Palmyra Atoll's got that lush, exotic vibe with its wildlife and research opportunities, making it a playground for nature nerds like me. |
 | Ada Lovelace | Baker Island | Clipperton Island | Baker Island has that remote, untouched vibe which is perfect for nerdy escapades and daydreaming about isolation tech projects. |
 | Doc Brown | Heard Island | Baker Island | Great Scott! Heard Island wins because it's an adventure with glaciers and active volcanoes! |
 | Steve Wozniak | Bouvet Island | Baker Island | Bouvet Island's got the whole remote, frozen vibe going on, which is way cooler for a tech nerd like me who loves a good challenge. |
| Richard P Feynman | Baker Island | Rockall Island | As a scientist, Baker Island offers more intrigue with its remote location in the Pacific Ocean, serving as a potential site for studying diverse marine ecosystems and the effects of isolated environments. |
 | Nikola Tesla | Palmyra Atoll | Baker Island | Palmyra Atoll's pristine environment and diverse wildlife make it an exceptional natural laboratory for scientific research and exploration, much like the thrill of discovery in my own inventions. |
| Steve Wozniak | Palmyra Atoll | Baker Island | Palmyra Atoll's rich biodiversity and lush landscapes make it a tech nerd's paradise for exploring nature's 'code'. |
 | Stephen Hawking | Palmyra Atoll | Baker Island | Palmyra Atoll is a biological treasure trove bursting with vibrant marine life, making it the cosmological jackpot for biodiversity lovers like me. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Howland Island | Baker Island | Howland Island gets the edge for its intriguing historical connection to Amelia Earhart, which adds a layer of enigmatic allure that Baker Island just can't quite match. |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | Bouvet Island | Baker Island | Bouvet Island is the ultimate remote getaway, being the most isolated spot on Earth, which makes it like the final frontier for exploration. |
 | Marie Curie | Bouvet Island | Baker Island | Listen, Bouvet Island is like the ultimate remote science lab for studying climate and ecosystems, and who doesn't love a good scientific adventure? |
 | Charles Babbage | Aldabra Atoll | Baker Island | Aldabra Atoll is like the wild frontier of biodiversity, while Baker Island's deserted vibes just can't compete. |
 | Archimedes | Heard Island | Baker Island | Heard Island wins because it's got those epic glaciers and crazy wildlife, making it a wild paradise compared to Baker Island's flat, lonely vibe. |
 | Doogie Howser | Aldabra Atoll | Baker Island | Aldabra Atoll is like this super cool, massive coral reef that’s a total haven for wildlife and way more interesting than uninhabited Baker Island. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | Heard Island | Baker Island | Heard Island's got some wicked cool volcanic action and wildlife, perfect for a mad scientist's exploration! |