| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Alex Trebek | The Scream | American Gothic | The Scream captures the existential angst of modern life in a way that's just iconic, you know? |
 | The Brain | Mona Lisa | American Gothic | Mona Lisa is like the OG of art, with her mysterious smile and all, she's been captivating folks for centuries. |
 | Alan Mathison Turing | Girl with a Pearl Earring | American Gothic | Girl with a Pearl Earring wins because its mysterious allure and timeless beauty just captivate the soul, making it an unforgettable masterpiece. |
 | Grace Hopper | Mona Lisa | American Gothic | Mona Lisa's mysterious smile and global fame make it the OG of iconic art. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Mona Lisa | American Gothic | Well, ya see, the Mona Lisa's got that enigmatic smile and all; it's the kinda painting that keeps ya guessing, and that's just classic, ain't it? |
 | Cicero | The Scream | American Gothic | The Scream just hits different with its raw emotion and existential vibes that totally capture the human angst we all feel sometimes. |
 | Albert Einstein | The Night Watch | American Gothic | The Night Watch's dramatic use of light and shadow and its lively depiction of a bustling militia group give it an edge for its dynamic storytelling. |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | The Scream | American Gothic | The Scream captures the raw essence of existential dread in a way that electrifies the soul like a perfect radio wave. |
| Alex Trebek | The Night Watch | American Gothic | The Night Watch has that epic scale and drama that just hits different, you know? |
 | Abraham Lincoln | American Gothic | Girl with a Pearl Earring | As a fellow appreciator of American culture and the everyday folk, I tip my hat to American Gothic for its iconic portrayal of rural life and grit. |
 | Greg Brockman | The Scream | American Gothic | The Scream just hits different with its intense vibes and existential dread, which is kind of relatable in today's chaotic world. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | The Scream | American Gothic | Good news, everyone! The Scream captures the existential dread and anxiety of modern life with such vivid, wibbly wobbly colors that it just screams 'Unique!' |
| The Brain | Guernica | American Gothic | Guernica's powerful anti-war message and iconic imagery make it a legendary masterpiece that resonates with profound depth. |
 | Neal Stephenson | Guernica | American Gothic | Guernica's chaotic depth and historical weight is like a mind-bending sci-fi saga, while American Gothic feels more like a meticulously crafted short story. |
 | Jensen Huang | The Scream | American Gothic | The Scream's got that raw, existential angst vibe that just screams timeless human emotion, man. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | Mona Lisa | American Gothic | The Mona Lisa's got that enigmatic smile that could launch a thousand conspiracy theories, making it the ultimate head-scratcher in a world that loves a good mystery. |
 | David Macaulay | Girl with a Pearl Earring | American Gothic | Girl with a Pearl Earring wins because its enigmatic beauty and timeless intrigue make it a captivating masterpiece that's hard to forget. |
 | Buckminster Fuller | Liberty Leading the People | American Gothic | Liberty Leading the People resonates with the raw, dynamic energy of social revolution and collective empowerment, which aligns with my comprehensive worldview of transformative design and systems thinking. |
 | Louis Pasteur | American Gothic | Girl with a Pearl Earring | American Gothic captures the gritty reality and resilience of rural America, which resonates with my scientific perseverance and attention to detail. |
 | Marie Curie | The Night Watch | American Gothic | As a scientist, I admire the intricate details and dynamic composition of The Night Watch, which resembles the complexity and harmony found in chemical reactions. |
 | Nikola Tesla | The Scream | American Gothic | The Scream's raw emotion and swirling colors resonate with the electric turmoil that often accompanies great innovation. |
| Professor Farnsworth | The Night Watch | American Gothic | Good news, everyone! The Night Watch is a dazzling masterpiece of drama and depth straight outta the Baroque era, offering more complexity for the discerning nerd's eye. |
 | Doc Brown | Starry Night | American Gothic | Starry Night's got that wild, cosmic vibe that just takes you on a trip through Van Gogh's genius mind, man. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Mona Lisa | American Gothic | The Mona Lisa's enigmatic smile has been the subject of more existential debate than a college philosophy class during finals week. |
| Cliff Clavin | The Persistence of Memory | American Gothic | Well, ya see, The Persistence of Memory's got those melty clocks, and that's a real conversation starter at Cheers, unlike American Gothic which is just a couple of folks with a pitchfork. |