| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | David Foster Wallace | War and Peace | The Odyssey | War and Peace is like a whole universe in a book, exploring the deepest corners of the human experience in a way that's just mind-blowing. |
 | Galileo | War and Peace | Paradise Lost | War and Peace, dude, it's like a freakin' epic saga of human life and history, while Paradise Lost is a bit too much on the whole heavy theological drama. |
| Galileo | War and Peace | The Aeneid | War and Peace's huge scope and real talk about history and human nature make it the heavyweight champ, even up against a legendary epic like The Aeneid. |
 | Cliff Clavin | War and Peace | Divine Comedy | Well, ya know, War and Peace is like the ultimate Russian novel, packed with history and drama, while the Divine Comedy is all sorts of poetic and allegorical, but ya gotta hand it to Tolstoy for the sheer scope and character depth, truly a masterpiece that offers a little somethin’ for everyone. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | War and Peace | The Odyssey | Great news, everyone! War and Peace intricately explores the human condition in a way that even a time-traveling nerd like me can appreciate over ancient epics. |
 | Pythagoras | War and Peace | Moby-Dick | War and Peace is like a massive, epic symphony on the human condition, weaving together history, philosophy, and a ton of characters in a way that just hits you right in the soul. |
 | Carl Sagan | War and Peace | The Odyssey | War and Peace offers a vast exploration of humanity in a historical context, which resonates deeply with my fascination with the intricate tapestry of human civilizations and the universe. |
 | Cicero | Divine Comedy | War and Peace | Dante's epic journey through the afterlife is a mind-blowing blend of imagination and philosophy that sets the standard for narrative poetry. |
 | Professor Frink | War and Peace | The Odyssey | Oh, glayvin! While The Odyssey is a timeless epic full of adventure and mythological wonders, War and Peace offers a sprawling narrative that intricately examines the complexities of human nature and society, which is a nerd's delight! |
 | Nikola Tesla | War and Peace | Moby-Dick | As a lover of intricate systems and human dynamics, War and Peace resonates more with my fascination for the interplay of history, science, and society. |
 | John von Neumann | War and Peace | The Iliad | War and Peace is like a grand symphony of human experience that captures the complexity of life in a way that resonates with my love for intricate systems and profound narratives. |
 | Jensen Huang | War and Peace | Moby-Dick | War and Peace is like the ultimate GPU of literature, with its epic scope and intricate detail, it processes the human condition on a massive scale. |
 | Andy Weir | War and Peace | Paradise Lost | War and Peace is like a novel on steroids, packing in all the drama, love, and historical depth you could ever want—it's the ultimate binge-read for nerds like me. |
 | Charles Darwin | War and Peace | The Odyssey | War and Peace is a sprawling masterpiece that delves deeply into human nature and history, much like my own voyage's exploration of the natural world. |
 | Albert Einstein | War and Peace | Les Misérables | While both are monumental works, War and Peace showcases an unparalleled depth of historical insight and philosophical reflection that resonates with my scientific curiosity about human nature and society. |
 | Belle | War and Peace | Paradise Lost | War and Peace is like the ultimate soap opera with epic battles and deep emotional drama, while Paradise Lost is heavy on the theology and poetic language; I vibe more with Tolstoy's storytelling style. |
 | Grace Hopper | War and Peace | Divine Comedy | War and Peace is like a sprawling epic with intricate characters and historical depth that just hits differently, like a game-changing mainframe upgrade. |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | War and Peace | Moby-Dick | War and Peace is like a full-course meal of human experience, while Moby-Dick is a deep dive into obsession with a single slice of life. |
 | Socrates | War and Peace | Moby-Dick | War and Peace is like a sprawling epic tapestry of human life, weaving together history, philosophy, and a plethora of characters in a way that leaves you thinking long after you've turned the last page. |
| Socrates | War and Peace | The Aeneid | War and Peace gives you this epic tapestry of life, history, and the human condition, bro, it's like living several lives in one read. |
| David Foster Wallace | War and Peace | Les Misérables | War and Peace gets it for blending the epic sweep of history with the minutiae of human experience in a way that just makes your neurons sizzle. |