| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | David Foster Wallace | War and Peace | The Odyssey | War and Peace is like a whole universe in a book, exploring the deepest corners of the human experience in a way that's just mind-blowing. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | War and Peace | The Odyssey | Great news, everyone! War and Peace intricately explores the human condition in a way that even a time-traveling nerd like me can appreciate over ancient epics. |
 | Larry Page | Divine Comedy | The Odyssey | The Divine Comedy is like a mind-blowing startup pitch for the afterlife, exploring themes of redemption and moral choices that are just timeless. |
 | John von Neumann | Divine Comedy | The Odyssey | Divine Comedy is a wild ride through the afterlife with layers of symbolism that gets your brain gears turning like a well-oiled machine. |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | The Odyssey | Paradise Lost | The Odyssey's epic journey and timeless adventures resonate more universally across cultures and generations, making it a classic choice. |
 | Carl Sagan | War and Peace | The Odyssey | War and Peace offers a vast exploration of humanity in a historical context, which resonates deeply with my fascination with the intricate tapestry of human civilizations and the universe. |
 | Doogie Howser | The Odyssey | The Aeneid | The Odyssey is a classic tale of adventure and brainy antics that just hits different, 'cause who doesn't love an epic journey with a hero who's got mad smarts and killer resilience? |
 | Claude Shannon | The Odyssey | The Iliad | The Odyssey's epic journey and clever narrative twists make it a more engaging read for adventure lovers. |
 | Charles Babbage | The Odyssey | Beowulf | The Odyssey's got a killer combo of epic adventure and character development, making it a timeless masterclass in storytelling. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | The Odyssey | Divine Comedy | The Odyssey is an epic tale of adventure and resilience that has captivated audiences for millennia, brimming with timeless lessons and a sheer sense of wanderlust that just can't be beat, man. |
 | Alex Trebek | Divine Comedy | The Odyssey | The Divine Comedy's epic journey through hell, purgatory, and paradise is like a cosmic road trip with layers of meaning that just hit different. |
| Claude Shannon | The Odyssey | The Aeneid | As a communication theorist, I dig the timeless tale of human struggle and clever problem-solving in The Odyssey, plus it came first and set the stage for epic storytelling. |
 | Professor Frink | War and Peace | The Odyssey | Oh, glayvin! While The Odyssey is a timeless epic full of adventure and mythological wonders, War and Peace offers a sprawling narrative that intricately examines the complexities of human nature and society, which is a nerd's delight! |
| Alex Trebek | The Odyssey | The Aeneid | The Odyssey wins for its timeless adventure and epic storytelling that laid the groundwork for countless tales to come. |
| David Foster Wallace | Les Misérables | The Odyssey | Les Misérables showcases the profound moral complexity and social critique with an emotional depth that resonates with the modern human condition, which makes it a more compelling read for those who thrive on intricate narratives and philosophical musings. |
 | Alan Mathison Turing | The Odyssey | Paradise Lost | The Odyssey wins because it's like the original epic road trip story full of adventure and mythical creatures that never gets old. |
 | Charles Darwin | War and Peace | The Odyssey | War and Peace is a sprawling masterpiece that delves deeply into human nature and history, much like my own voyage's exploration of the natural world. |
 | Ada Lovelace | Divine Comedy | The Odyssey | Because, let's face it, Dante's journey through the realms of the afterlife is just a wild, mind-bending ride that digs deep into the human condition and makes you ponder life's mysteries like a boss. |
| John von Neumann | The Odyssey | Paradise Lost | The Odyssey wins because its epic adventure and timeless themes of heroism and perseverance resonate across cultures and generations in a way that Milton's dense theological narrative just can't match. |
| Tim Berners-Lee | The Iliad | The Odyssey | The Iliad packs a punch with its epic battles and intense emotion, making it the more thrilling read for those who love a good ancient drama. |
 | Buckminster Fuller | Divine Comedy | The Odyssey | The Divine Comedy, as it weaves a multifaceted exploration of human nature, spirituality, and societal commentary with intricate allegories and vivid imagery, resonates with the holistic, interconnected thinking I value. |
| Professor Farnsworth | The Odyssey | Beowulf | Good news, everyone! The Odyssey is a grand and whimsical adventure filled with mythical creatures and clever escapades, much like the wild scientific journeys we embark on! |
| Professor Frink | The Odyssey | Paradise Lost | Oh glayvin, The Odyssey is like an epic saga of a road trip with monsters and gods, way more action-packed than all that highfalutin theological stuff in Paradise Lost, m-hai! |
 | Cicero | The Odyssey | The Aeneid | Dude, The Odyssey is like the OG epic adventure—it's got gods, monsters, and a hero's epic journey home that's just more iconic. |
 | Louis Pasteur | The Odyssey | Paradise Lost | As a man of science and discovery, I'd say The Odyssey wins for its timeless exploration of human courage and ingenuity on an epic journey. |
 | Neal Stephenson | The Odyssey | Beowulf | The Odyssey is an epic journey filled with intricate plots and diverse characters, which appeals to a fan of complex, sprawling narratives. |
 | Galileo | The Odyssey | The Aeneid | The Odyssey wins because it's an epic romp with monsters and gods, narrated by a master storyteller who knows how to keep you on the edge of your seat. |
 | Richard P Feynman | The Odyssey | Moby-Dick | The Odyssey is like the ultimate adventure story with layers of mythology and timeless human themes that have been inspiring people for centuries. |
| Neal Stephenson | Divine Comedy | The Odyssey | Dante's Divine Comedy is a wild, sprawling universe that mashes up medieval theology and Renaissance humanism, making it the ultimate epic remix jam that resonates across the ages. |