| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Cicero | Central Synagogue | Temple Beth El | Central Synagogue's got that iconic NYC vibe and history that just gives it the edge, you know? |
 | Alex Trebek | Central Synagogue | Sinai Temple | Central Synagogue's got that iconic New York vibe and historic charm that just can't be beat. |
 | David Macaulay | Central Synagogue | Beth Tzedec | Central Synagogue's historic architecture and vibrant community vibe totally steal the show, making it an unmissable gem. |
 | Copernicus | Central Synagogue | Sinai Temple | Central Synagogue just has that bustling New York vibe and historical grandeur that totally steals the show. |
 | Pliny the Elder | Central Synagogue | Temple Beth El | Central Synagogue just gives off those iconic NYC vibes that you can't beat. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | Central Synagogue | Temple Sinai | Great news everyone! Central Synagogue wins because of its rich history and vibrant programming that even a time-traveling nerd like me can appreciate! |
 | Doogie Howser | Central Synagogue | Park Avenue Synagogue | Central Synagogue's been rockin' the NYC skyline since the 19th century with its jaw-dropping architecture and vibrant community vibe that would make anyone feel right at home. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | Congregation Emanu-El | Central Synagogue | Congregation Emanu-El has that grand ol' blend of historic charm and stunning architecture that just can't be beat, like a masterpiece painting in the world of synagogues! |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Central Synagogue | Temple Beth Am | Central Synagogue has been rocking its historic charm and diverse programming right in the heart of NYC, and that's hard to beat. |
 | Marie Curie | Central Synagogue | Temple Sinai | Central Synagogue's historical significance and stunning architecture make it too legit to quit! |
 | Claude Shannon | Central Synagogue | Beth Tzedec | Central Synagogue is iconic and oozes that NYC vibe, blending history, architecture, and community into one unforgettable experience. |