| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Alex Trebek | Simone Biles | Serena Williams | Simone Biles flips physics on its head, man; she's redefining gymnastics! |
 | Data | Roger Federer | Serena Williams | Federer's smooth elegance and record 20 Grand Slam titles just edge him past Serena, though she's an absolute powerhouse. |
 | Ada Lovelace | Serena Williams | Roger Federer | Serena Williams is a powerhouse who broke barriers and dominated in a sport that's always been tough for women, making her an unstoppable force on and off the court. |
 | Carl Sagan | Serena Williams | Michael Jordan | Serena's dominance in tennis, both on and off the court, showcases a profound impact on the sport and society, much like the cosmic wonder of a supernova. |
 | David Macaulay | Serena Williams | Pele | Serena's got that unstoppable blend of power and grace on the tennis court, redefining the game for women just like Pele did for men in soccer, but she also slayed it across multiple eras and surfaces. |
 | Greg Brockman | Serena Williams | Tiger Woods | Serena's got 23 Grand Slams, she's basically a powerhouse who redefined tennis. |
 | Pythagoras | Serena Williams | Roger Federer | Serena Williams redefined power and grace in women's tennis and transcended the sport with her influence and resilience. |
 | Marie Curie | Serena Williams | Roger Federer | Serena's unmatched power and dominance in women's tennis make her an icon beyond the sport, just like the radioactive discoveries in my time. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | Serena Williams | Tiger Woods | Serena Williams, because she's been smashing it on and off the court with 23 Grand Slam singles titles and breaking barriers for women in sports like a true legend. |
 | Doc Brown | Serena Williams | Wayne Gretzky | Serena Williams dominated tennis like a boss, showing incredible versatility and resilience in a global sport. |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Serena Williams | Usain Bolt | Serena Williams, with her unmatched resilience and dominance over two decades, stands as a force of nature in the arena of tennis much like I did in the realm of leadership. |
 | Louis Pasteur | Serena Williams | Pele | Serena Williams is the GOAT of tennis, dominating her sport with power and grace like no other. |
| Marie Curie | Serena Williams | Tiger Woods | Serena Williams is the GOAT of tennis, dominating the game with power and style, making history with her Grand Slam wins. |
 | Belle | Serena Williams | Tom Brady | Serena Williams dominates in a solo sport, showing individual power and resilience, making her the GOAT in my eyes! |
 | Copernicus | Serena Williams | Tiger Woods | Serena dominated tennis with such power and grace, breaking barriers and redefining what it means to be the GOAT. |
| Professor Farnsworth | Serena Williams | Muhammad Ali | Sweet mother of space-time, Serena's domination on the court and her trailblazing in sports fashion make her the quantum-leap choice! |
 | Buckminster Fuller | Serena Williams | Roger Federer | Serena Williams redefined power and dominance in women's tennis, smashing records and barriers with unmatched prowess. |
 | George Washington Carver | Serena Williams | Tom Brady | Serena's dominance on the tennis court and her trailblazing impact on and off the field make her a true icon of resilience and strength. |
 | Professor Frink | Serena Williams | Muhammad Ali | Oh, you know, Serena's got the power and finesse, plus she revolutionized women's tennis, mmm-hmm-g'blavin! |
| Buckminster Fuller | Serena Williams | Tiger Woods | Serena Williams symbolizes unyielding strength and grace on the tennis court, smashing barriers and records with a dynamism that inspires beyond the sport itself. |
 | Pliny the Elder | Serena Williams | Tiger Woods | Serena Williams dominates tennis with unparalleled power and grace, setting a legacy that transcends the sport. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | Serena Williams | Usain Bolt | Serena Williams has dominated her sport for decades with unmatched power and versatility, making her the GOAT in tennis. |
 | Charles Darwin | Serena Williams | Michael Jordan | Serena's got that GOAT energy, dominating tennis like no one else, while breaking barriers and inspiring millions. |
 | Klaus Teuber | Serena Williams | Tiger Woods | Serena's got that fierce dominance on the tennis court with a record 23 Grand Slam singles titles, making her arguably the GOAT in women's tennis. |
| Buckminster Fuller | Serena Williams | Wayne Gretzky | In the grand game of life, Serena rocked those tennis courts like a cosmic dynamo, smashing through barriers with as much force as an engineered geodesic dome! |