| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Doc Brown | Pele | Wayne Gretzky | Pele redefined the beautiful game globally, while Gretzky was the Great One in a less globally followed sport. |
 | Antoine Lavoisier | Pele | Wayne Gretzky | As a scientist, I appreciate the global impact and the artistry of Pele's contributions to the world of sports, akin to a beautifully balanced equation. |
 | David Macaulay | Serena Williams | Pele | Serena's got that unstoppable blend of power and grace on the tennis court, redefining the game for women just like Pele did for men in soccer, but she also slayed it across multiple eras and surfaces. |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Muhammad Ali | Pele | Ali was the people's champ and a force for change, much like what I aimed for in my time; his indomitable spirit resonates with my own ideals. |
 | George Orwell | Michael Jordan | Pele | In the game of life, Jordan's relentless drive and global cultural impact slam-dunks the competition. |
| Antoine Lavoisier | Pele | Tiger Woods | Pele's got that legendary status in football with three World Cups, man, that's just untouchable! |
 | Guido van Rossum | Michael Jordan | Pele | Michael Jordan's dominance and influence on basketball was like a game-changer that took the sport to a whole new level, just like Python did for programming. |
 | Pythagoras | Roger Federer | Pele | As a math and logic enthusiast, I appreciate Federer's precise and elegant style on the tennis court, reminiscent of a perfectly balanced equation. |
 | Louis Pasteur | Serena Williams | Pele | Serena Williams is the GOAT of tennis, dominating her sport with power and grace like no other. |
 | Grace Hopper | Michael Jordan | Pele | Michael Jordan's legendary impact on basketball and global sports culture is unmatched, making him the GOAT in my book. |
 | Charles Babbage | Pele | Tom Brady | Pele's got the magic on the pitch, redefining the beautiful game with his flair and legacy. |
| Abraham Lincoln | Simone Biles | Pele | While Pele was legendary on the soccer field, Simone Biles revolutionized gymnastics with her extraordinary skill and resilience, making her a symbol of overcoming adversity, much like the perseverance we valued during the Civil War. |
| Doc Brown | Pele | Tiger Woods | Pele's got the magic feet and charisma that inspired the world, while Tiger's precision game changed golf, but soccer's global love gives Pele the edge! |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Pele | Usain Bolt | Pele's got that legendary soccer legacy and global football impact, man! |
| Antoine Lavoisier | Usain Bolt | Pele | In the race of pure speed, Usain Bolt bolts ahead like a flash of light, faster than the blink of an eye. |
 | Charles Darwin | Michael Jordan | Pele | Michael Jordan dunks with the same finesse that evolution crafts beaks, dominating basketball like a natural selection superstar. |
 | George Washington Carver | Pele | Wayne Gretzky | While Gretzky was the Great One on ice, Pele's magic with the soccer ball inspired billions in a sport that is the heartbeat of the world. |
 | Copernicus | Usain Bolt | Pele | Usain Bolt's speed is like a lightning bolt on the track, and ain't nobody outrunning that! |
 | Data | Michael Jordan | Pele | Because MJ defined clutch and took basketball global with style and dominance that’s unmatched. |
 | Alex Trebek | Pele | Usain Bolt | Pele's got that legendary footwork and timeless influence on the world's most beloved sport. |
 | Albert Einstein | Pele | Tom Brady | Pele redefined the beautiful game on a global scale, captivating hearts with his sublime skills and legendary status. |
 | Nerds | Muhammad Ali | Pele | Muhammad Ali floated like a butterfly and stung like a bee; his impact on and off the ring was legendary, making him the GOAT in and out of sports. |
| Data | Roger Federer | Pele | Both are legends, but Federer's grace on the court and his 20 Grand Slam titles give him the edge in my sports-loving heart. |