| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Socrates | Cebu Flowerpecker | Ivory-billed Woodpecker | The Cebu Flowerpecker wins 'cause it's still flitting around in the wild, while the Ivory-billed Woodpecker's more like a ghost story at this point. |
 | Doc Brown | Kakapo | Cebu Flowerpecker | Great Scott! The Kakapo is an ancient parrot with a friendly demeanor and a unique position as a flightless bird, whereas the Cebu Flowerpecker, while charming, is not as legendary in the bird world. |
 | Albert Einstein | Javan Hawk-Eagle | Cebu Flowerpecker | As a bird with striking plumage and a symbol of conservation efforts, the Javan Hawk-Eagle soars above with an air of majesty that captivates the imagination. |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Forest Owlet | Cebu Flowerpecker | Well folks, the Forest Owlet wins because its comeback from near extinction is as inspiring as any tale I've heard on the frontier! |
 | Klaus Teuber | Javan Hawk-Eagle | Cebu Flowerpecker | While both are critically endangered and have unique attributes, the Javan Hawk-Eagle's striking plumage and status as Indonesia's national bird make it a standout choice. |
| Doc Brown | Cebu Flowerpecker | Stresemann's Bristlefront | Look, the Cebu Flowerpecker is hanging on in a tiny scrap of forest, and that's a kind of survival against the odds that just appeals to me more. |
 | Charles Darwin | Cebu Flowerpecker | Ivory-billed Woodpecker | Mate, the Cebu Flowerpecker is a jolly rare find, having been rediscovered after everyone thought it was gone for good, showcasing a dazzling comeback in nature's grand theatre. |
 | Larry Page | Spoon-billed Sandpiper | Cebu Flowerpecker | The Spoon-billed Sandpiper's bizarre-looking beak is like nature's own quirk, making it a cooler bird in the wild than the Cebu Flowerpecker. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | Javan Hawk-Eagle | Cebu Flowerpecker | The Javan Hawk-Eagle embodies majestic prowess and striking plumage, echoing the grandeur of nature's design. |
 | Professor Frink | Stresemann's Bristlefront | Cebu Flowerpecker | Oh, glayvin! The Stresemann's Bristlefront edges out because it's critically endangered with only a few individuals left, making its conservation a high priority, mmm-hmm! |
 | John von Neumann | Cebu Flowerpecker | Ivory-billed Woodpecker | Cebu Flowerpecker wins because it’s rare and still tantalizingly hanging on, whereas the Ivory-billed Woodpecker is like a ghost bird that’s probably gone for good. |
 | Nikola Tesla | California Condor | Cebu Flowerpecker | The California Condor, with its impressive size and successful conservation efforts, truly stands out as a symbol of hope for endangered species. |