| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Lonnie Johnson | This American Life | The Joe Rogan Experience | As a nerd with a penchant for storytelling and depth, This American Life's narrative-driven content and insightful perspectives resonate more with my curious nature. |
 | Archimedes | This American Life | The Joe Rogan Experience | Dude, This American Life just nails storytelling with depth and insight, bringing layers to real-life experiences. |
 | Pliny the Elder | This American Life | Office Ladies | This American Life spins stories like a bard with a podcast mic, weaving tales that stick with you long after the credits roll. |
 | Guido van Rossum | This American Life | Call Her Daddy | This American Life's storytelling and depth resonate more with my nerdy love for compelling narratives and insightful journalism. |
 | Marie Curie | This American Life | Stuff You Should Know | As a scientist who values deep storytelling and diverse perspectives, This American Life resonates more with my penchant for exploring the human condition and societal complexities. |
| Guido van Rossum | This American Life | Office Ladies | As a classic nerd who loves a good story, This American Life just hits that sweet spot for captivating narratives every time. |
 | Louis Pasteur | This American Life | SmartLess | As a scientist and a man of detail, I appreciate the depth and storytelling finesse that This American Life consistently delivers. |
 | Professor Frink | Stuff You Should Know | This American Life | Great glayvin! Stuff You Should Know is like a delightful nerd buffet, offering endless curiosity and knowledge snacks, oh boy! |
 | Buckminster Fuller | This American Life | Office Ladies | As a comprehensive thinker, I appreciate the wide-ranging narratives and socio-cultural insights This American Life offers, which resonates with my holistic perspective on the world. |
| Louis Pasteur | This American Life | Office Ladies | As a scientist who loves storytelling, This American Life's compelling narratives and diverse topics are like a well-balanced culture broth to my curious mind. |
 | Doogie Howser | This American Life | SmartLess | I'm all about those rich stories and emotional depth, so This American Life takes the cake! |
 | The Brain | This American Life | Morbid | This American Life has been an OG in storytelling, with mad skills in mixing up topics, so it kinda takes the crown. |
 | Stephen Hawking | This American Life | Morbid | This American Life is like a fascinating tour through the human condition, with stories that are as thought-provoking as a black hole's mysteries. |
 | Charles Babbage | This American Life | Morbid | This American Life's storytelling is just next-level, bringing a variety of human experiences right to your ears in a way that's both captivating and thought-provoking. |
| Pliny the Elder | This American Life | The Daily | This American Life just hits different with its storytelling magic that keeps every episode feeling like a personal journey. |
 | Doc Brown | This American Life | Morbid | This American Life is like the DeLorean of storytelling, taking you on a wild ride through diverse, thought-provoking tales that stick with you long after you've hit 88 mph. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | This American Life | Crime Junkie | This American Life, because it's like opening a box of assorted gourmet chocolates for the mind, each episode offering a distinct flavor of storytelling. |
 | John von Neumann | This American Life | Call Her Daddy | This American Life brings that intellectual storytelling vibe, perfect for a nerd like me who loves deep dives into human stories and data. |
| Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | This American Life | The Daily | This American Life's storytelling is like assembling a beautiful creature from disparate parts—it's alive with emotion and creativity! |
| Charles Babbage | This American Life | Call Her Daddy | This American Life is like a deep dive into the human experience, perfect for the introspective nerd in me. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | This American Life | The Daily | Because 'This American Life' weaves together the wild tapestry of human experience with a wit and whimsy that would make Kilgore Trout tip his hat. |
 | Charles Darwin | Stuff You Should Know | This American Life | As an inquisitive nerd who loves a deep dive into random topics, Stuff You Should Know tickles my curiosity in all the right ways. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | This American Life | Crime Junkie | As a lover of stories and human experiences, This American Life paints a broad and rich tapestry that feels more akin to the art I admire. |