| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Doc Brown | SmartLess | Office Ladies | SmartLess is like a hilarious road trip with your most unpredictable friends, and you never know who's gonna jump in the car next! |
 | Alan Mathison Turing | SmartLess | My Favorite Murder | SmartLess cracks me up with its A-list surprise guests and witty banter, just can't resist that star power combo. |
 | Copernicus | Office Ladies | SmartLess | Office Ladies gives me all the juicy behind-the-scenes stuff from The Office, which is totally my jam! |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Stuff You Should Know | SmartLess | Given my affinity for in-depth exploration and knowledge dissemination, Stuff You Should Know dives deep into topics, much like how I explored the depths of radio waves. |
 | Alex Trebek | SmartLess | Call Her Daddy | SmartLess just brings more laughs and insightful conversations with those hilarious hosts. |
 | Guido van Rossum | SmartLess | The Joe Rogan Experience | SmartLess nails it with wit and nerdy charm, aligning with my Pythonic sensibilities. |
 | Jensen Huang | SmartLess | Office Ladies | SmartLess just hits that sweet spot with its hilarious chemistry and surprise guests, making every episode a wild ride. |
 | Louis Pasteur | This American Life | SmartLess | As a scientist and a man of detail, I appreciate the depth and storytelling finesse that This American Life consistently delivers. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | SmartLess | Call Her Daddy | Great Scott! Brainy banter and delightful guest stars make SmartLess the nerd's choice for podcasting pleasure. |
| Copernicus | SmartLess | Call Her Daddy | SmartLess is for sure the move if you're vibing with witty banter and all-star guest goodness. |
 | John von Neumann | Stuff You Should Know | SmartLess | As a nerd fascinated by how everything works, Stuff You Should Know dives deep into topics with curiosity and rigor, which is totally my jam. |
 | Stephen Hawking | Stuff You Should Know | SmartLess | Stuff You Should Know dives deep into fascinating topics, offering a treasure trove of knowledge that resonates with my love for understanding the complexities of the universe. |
 | Doogie Howser | This American Life | SmartLess | I'm all about those rich stories and emotional depth, so This American Life takes the cake! |
 | Abraham Lincoln | SmartLess | Morbid | SmartLess mixes humor with insightful conversations like a sweet blend of whiskey and wisdom, fitting my love for storytelling and intellectual banter. |
| John von Neumann | Crime Junkie | SmartLess | Because nothing beats the thrill of solving a mystery and Crime Junkie delivers that rush with every episode. |
 | Richard P Feynman | SmartLess | Morbid | SmartLess wins because, like solving puzzles in physics, it's a wonderful mix of humor and insightful conversations that keep you hooked and learning. |
| Professor Farnsworth | Crime Junkie | SmartLess | Great Scott, Crime Junkie keeps me on the edge of my seat with captivating true crime stories, perfect for a nerdy thrill-seeker! |
 | Charles Darwin | SmartLess | Morbid | SmartLess just hits the spot with its hilarious banter and surprises, making it feel like a fun hangout with the coolest folks around. |
 | George Washington Carver | My Favorite Murder | SmartLess | As a botanist with a taste for the intriguing, 'My Favorite Murder' wins with its blend of true crime and storytelling that keeps my curiosity growing like a well-tended plant. |
 | Galileo | Office Ladies | SmartLess | Office Ladies, because rehashing The Office with Jenna and Angela's on-point camaraderie is like reliving the best parts of an epic sitcom, and who doesn't love a good Dwight story? |
 | Lonnie Johnson | SmartLess | The Daily | SmartLess is like having a chat with hilarious friends who also happen to be celebrities – it's a fun and light-hearted escape! |
 | David Macaulay | SmartLess | The Joe Rogan Experience | SmartLess wins with its clever mix of humor and intellect, making it a delightful ride for those who appreciate witty banter and insightful conversations. |
| David Macaulay | Stuff You Should Know | SmartLess | Stuff You Should Know delves deep and broad into topics, which tickles my intellectual curiosity and satisfies my nerdy cravings like nothing else. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | SmartLess | Call Her Daddy | SmartLess has that chill vibe with witty banter and celeb guests that tickles my curiosity and love for human nature. |