| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Archimedes | My Favorite Murder | Crime Junkie | My Favorite Murder keeps it real with humor and personality, makin' you feel like you're just chillin' with friends while diving into true crime. |
 | Albert Einstein | Stuff You Should Know | Crime Junkie | As someone who's all about unraveling the mysteries of the universe, I dig how 'Stuff You Should Know' breaks down complex topics in a fun and enlightening way, much like how I enjoyed peeling back the layers of physics! |
 | Jensen Huang | Crime Junkie | My Favorite Murder | Crime Junkie just hits differently with its straightforward storytelling and thorough research, making it the go-to for die-hard true crime fans. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | My Favorite Murder | Crime Junkie | Good news, everyone! 'My Favorite Murder' wins for its delightful mix of true crime and comedy that even a mad scientist like me can appreciate. |
 | Belle | Crime Junkie | The Joe Rogan Experience | Crime Junkie is like a suspenseful mystery movie every week, while Joe Rogan can be a mixed bag of guests and topics. |
 | John von Neumann | Crime Junkie | SmartLess | Because nothing beats the thrill of solving a mystery and Crime Junkie delivers that rush with every episode. |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | My Favorite Murder | Crime Junkie | My Favorite Murder has a more conversational tone that's like chatting with friends, which resonates with my love for lively and engaging communication. |
 | Neal Stephenson | My Favorite Murder | Crime Junkie | My Favorite Murder has that quirky, conversational style that feels like hanging out with your snarky friends, which aligns with my love for narrative depth and personality. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | This American Life | Crime Junkie | This American Life, because it's like opening a box of assorted gourmet chocolates for the mind, each episode offering a distinct flavor of storytelling. |
| Professor Farnsworth | Crime Junkie | SmartLess | Great Scott, Crime Junkie keeps me on the edge of my seat with captivating true crime stories, perfect for a nerdy thrill-seeker! |
| Belle | Crime Junkie | The Daily | Crime Junkie keeps me on the edge of my seat with thrilling true crime tales, perfect for a nerdy mystery lover like me. |
 | Steve Wozniak | Stuff You Should Know | Crime Junkie | Stuff You Should Know wins because it dives into a wide range of topics with geeky enthusiasm, which is right up my alley! |
 | David Macaulay | Office Ladies | Crime Junkie | As a nerd who loves architecture and detailed breakdowns, I dig the deep dives and behind-the-scenes tidbits of Office Ladies—it’s like building a skyscraper with words! |
| John von Neumann | My Favorite Murder | Crime Junkie | My Favorite Murder's comedic storytelling and personable hosts make it a killer listen. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | This American Life | Crime Junkie | As a lover of stories and human experiences, This American Life paints a broad and rich tapestry that feels more akin to the art I admire. |