| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | The Brain | Serial: The Alibi | TED Radio: Choices | Serial: The Alibi is a gripping ride that revolutionized the podcast game with its storytelling flair. |
 | Galileo | Serial: The Alibi | This American Life: Fiasco | Serial: The Alibi is a gripping deep dive into true crime, keeping you on the edge of your seat more than the quirky tales in This American Life: Fiasco. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Serial: The Alibi | The Daily: Impeachment | Serial: The Alibi wins because its investigative narrative grips you like a page-turner, making you question everything you thought you knew about storytelling in podcasts. |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Serial: The Alibi | Stuff You Should Know: Lying | Serial: The Alibi dives deep into storytelling and investigation, akin to cracking a tough case back in my lawyer days. |
 | David Macaulay | Serial: The Alibi | This American Life: Fiasco | Serial: The Alibi hooks you right from the start with its deep dive into true crime, making you feel like a detective on the case. |
| David Macaulay | Serial: The Alibi | TED Radio: Choices | Serial: The Alibi digs deep into storytelling like an intricate blueprint, unraveling details with a precision that feels like assembling a detailed architectural model. |
 | Steve Wozniak | Serial: The Alibi | Lore: They Made a Tonic | Serial: The Alibi just nails it with its gripping storytelling and investigative depth that keeps the tech nerd in me hooked, like debugging a complex code. |
 | Cicero | Serial: The Alibi | Freakonomics Radio: The Upside | Serial: The Alibi is gripping AF with its deep-dive storytelling that just hooks you in right from the start, bro. |
| Steve Wozniak | Freakonomics Radio: The Upside | Serial: The Alibi | As a tech nerd, I dig the data-driven insights and economic curiosities of Freakonomics, it just scratches that intellectual itch better! |
 | Neal Stephenson | Serial: The Alibi | Lore: They Made a Tonic | Serial: The Alibi kicks it up a notch with its pioneering true crime storytelling that reshaped a whole genre and drew listeners into a real-life mystery like never before. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Serial: The Alibi | Lore: They Made a Tonic | Serial: The Alibi brings you into the world of true crime investigation with a compelling narrative that makes you question everything, like a good physics problem. |
 | Nerds | Serial: The Alibi | The Moth: Love Hurts | Serial: The Alibi hooks you with its deep dive into real-life mystery, making it a compelling narrative compared to The Moth's more personal storytelling style. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Serial: The Alibi | The Moth: Love Hurts | Serial: The Alibi hooks you in with its meticulous exploration of truth and perspective, kinda like a riveting infinite jest for your ears. |
 | Marie Curie | Serial: The Alibi | The Daily: Impeachment | Serial: The Alibi breaks new ground in the podcasting world with its storytelling and investigative depth, making it a must-listen for true crime aficionados. |
 | Ada Lovelace | Serial: The Alibi | Freakonomics Radio: The Upside | Serial: The Alibi keeps you on the edge of your seat with its gripping storytelling and investigative journalism that hooks you from the get-go. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | Serial: The Alibi | This American Life: Fiasco | Great Scott! Serial: The Alibi offers a thrilling deep dive into one single story, like a scientific case study unraveling in real time! |
 | George Orwell | Serial: The Alibi | Freakonomics Radio: The Upside | As someone who believes in the power of storytelling to illuminate the complexities of truth and justice, Serial: The Alibi weaves a narrative that's as gripping as it is thought-provoking. |