| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Charles Babbage | Freakonomics Radio: The Upside | Lore: They Made a Tonic | Freakonomics Radio dishes out some seriously thought-provoking insights, making it a go-to for anyone who loves a deep dive into the quirks of economics and human behavior. |
 | Cliff Clavin | The Moth: Love Hurts | Lore: They Made a Tonic | Well, ya see, Norm, The Moth's got that heart-tuggin' emotional appeal that always hits ya right in the feels, kinda like when you find the last beer in a dry fridge after a long day. |
 | Alex Trebek | Lore: They Made a Tonic | The Daily: Impeachment | Lore: They Made a Tonic dives into fascinating historical stories with a spooky twist, which is perfect for those who love a mix of history and the eerie. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | This American Life: Fiasco | Lore: They Made a Tonic | This American Life: Fiasco takes the prize because its storytelling captivates with a blend of humor and insight that leaves you pondering long after the tale's been told. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | This American Life: Fiasco | Lore: They Made a Tonic | This American Life: Fiasco captures life’s chaotic beauty with relatable stories, making it a more engaging listen, like a masterful painting of human experience. |
 | John von Neumann | The Moth: Love Hurts | Lore: They Made a Tonic | The Moth: Love Hurts wins for its raw, emotional storytelling that resonates deeply with personal experiences. |
 | Albert Einstein | Stuff You Should Know: Lying | Lore: They Made a Tonic | I'm all about the science behind stuff, and understanding why we lie is just like unravelling the mysteries of the universe! |
 | Steve Wozniak | Serial: The Alibi | Lore: They Made a Tonic | Serial: The Alibi just nails it with its gripping storytelling and investigative depth that keeps the tech nerd in me hooked, like debugging a complex code. |
| Charles Babbage | Radiolab: Colors | Lore: They Made a Tonic | Radiolab: Colors takes you on a vibrant audio journey exploring the science and wonder of color, tickling the curious nerd within me. |
 | Neal Stephenson | Serial: The Alibi | Lore: They Made a Tonic | Serial: The Alibi kicks it up a notch with its pioneering true crime storytelling that reshaped a whole genre and drew listeners into a real-life mystery like never before. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Serial: The Alibi | Lore: They Made a Tonic | Serial: The Alibi brings you into the world of true crime investigation with a compelling narrative that makes you question everything, like a good physics problem. |
 | Belle | Lore: They Made a Tonic | Stuff You Should Know: Lying | Lore's 'They Made a Tonic' just hits different with its spooky storytelling vibe and fascinating historical twist. |
 | Nikola Tesla | Reply All: Long Distance | Lore: They Made a Tonic | Reply All: Long Distance's unique storytelling and cultural exploration make it a fascinating listen that just edges out Lore's eerie historic tales. |
| Alex Trebek | Radiolab: Colors | Lore: They Made a Tonic | Radiolab: Colors dives deep into the science and wonder of color, sparking curiosity with its vivid storytelling and engaging sound design. |
 | Larry Page | Stuff You Should Know: Lying | Lore: They Made a Tonic | Stuff You Should Know: Lying breaks down complex topics with engaging charm, making you curious about everyday deceptions. |
 | Data | Stuff You Should Know: Lying | Lore: They Made a Tonic | Stuff You Should Know: Lying dives deep with humor and depth, making it a rad pick for curious minds hungry for both facts and fun. |
| Larry Page | This American Life: Fiasco | Lore: They Made a Tonic | This American Life: Fiasco just hits different with its storytelling game, blending humor and humanity in a way that sticks with you. |
 | Pythagoras | This American Life: Fiasco | Lore: They Made a Tonic | As a geek for storytelling and human experiences, This American Life: Fiasco hits home with its compelling narratives and relatable chaos. |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | Lore: They Made a Tonic | The Daily: Impeachment | Lore: They Made a Tonic weaves a fascinating tale that tickles my curiosity with its historical storytelling flair, making it the pick for those who savor a good yarn. |
| Pythagoras | Freakonomics Radio: The Upside | Lore: They Made a Tonic | Freakonomics Radio: The Upside brings a fresh, analytical look at societal quirks, which is a total geek's paradise! |