| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Klaus Teuber | Isla San Juan | Thule Island | Isla San Juan is like a strategic gold mine for settlers and traders, perfect for building a thriving Catan-style settlement. |
 | George Orwell | Hy-Brasil | Thule Island | Ah, the mysterious Hy-Brasil, a mirage of myth and mystery, always seems to captivate the imagination more than barren Thule. |
 | Antoine Lavoisier | Thule Island | Bermeja | Thule Island is real and present in the South Atlantic, whereas Bermeja is a ghost of cartography, never truly found or verified. |
 | The Brain | Thule Island | Bermeja | Thule Island actually exists, while Bermeja is like the ghost of islands—legendary but unconfirmed. |
 | Nikola Tesla | Thule Island | Royal Company's Island | Thule Island is more intriguing due to its remote volcanic nature, making it a hotspot for geological wonders! |
 | Belle | Thule Island | Crocker Land | Thule Island is a real place you can actually visit, while Crocker Land is just a mythical ghost of an island that never existed. |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Thule Island | Bermeja | Mate, Thule Island's got real estate you can actually visit, while Bermeja's a phantom isle—Thule wins by default! |
| Nikola Tesla | Thule Island | Bermeja | Thule Island's dramatic volcanic landscape and real-world existence trump the mysterious absence of Bermeja any day! |
 | Pythagoras | Hy-Brasil | Thule Island | Hy-Brasil wins because it's the mysterious island of legends, while Thule Island is just another cold rock in the middle of nowhere. |
 | Greg Brockman | Isla San Juan | Thule Island | Isla San Juan vibes with chill island adventures, unlike Thule's icy no-man's land feel. |
 | Socrates | Isla San Juan | Thule Island | Isla San Juan is chill with its cool Pacific vibes and scenic views, bro! |
 | Buckminster Fuller | Thule Island | Bermeja | Thule Island is a real place you can actually visit, whereas Bermeja is a phantom island that continues to elude explorers and maps. |
 | Ada Lovelace | Thule Island | Crocker Land | Thule Island is a real place you can actually visit, while Crocker Land turned out to be just a figment of the imagination. |
 | Jensen Huang | Thule Island | Podesta | Thule Island's rugged landscapes and remote allure make it the ultimate getaway for an adventurous soul like me, where every corner is an untapped dataset of natural wonder. |
 | Andy Weir | Thule Island | Royal Company's Island | Thule Island wins because it's got that cool, remote vibe and a history of being a mysterious volcanic island in the South Sandwich Islands, which is just nerdy enough to pique my interest. |
 | Galileo | Thule Island | Saxemberg Island | Thule Island is the real deal, a legit island with actual land you can visit, while Saxemberg Island is just a sailor's tall tale, it never existed! |
 | Albert Einstein | Thule Island | Podesta | As a scientist with an appreciation for natural wonders, Thule Island's unique volcanic landscape and remote beauty win hands down over something like Podesta. |
 | Nerds | Thule Island | Sarah Ann Island | Thule Island's got dramatic volcanic vibes and some cool research history, while Sarah Ann Island is just a phantom that vanished from maps! |
| George Orwell | Thule Island | Crocker Land | Thule Island is real and known, while Crocker Land turned out to be an arctic mirage—much ado about nothin'. |