| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Nikola Tesla | Saxemberg Island | Podesta | Saxemberg Island is shrouded in mystery and aligns with my love for the unknown and unexplored wonders of the world. |
 | David Macaulay | Saxemberg Island | Bermeja | Saxemberg Island has a mysterious allure with its history of sightings and disappearances, just like a real-life treasure hunt in the middle of the ocean! |
 | Charles Darwin | Isla Grande | Saxemberg Island | Isla Grande is real and bustling with life, while Saxemberg Island is just a mysterious ghost of sailor tales. |
| Nikola Tesla | Crocker Land | Saxemberg Island | Neither island actually exists, but Crocker Land had a cooler exploration story involving brave explorers facing Arctic conditions, which sparks the adventurous spirit of discovery I cherish. |
 | Cicero | Saxemberg Island | Crocker Land | Saxemberg Island gets the edge 'cause it's got more of a mysterious vibe, being a phantom island and all, whereas Crocker Land was just a big ol' Arctic mirage. |
 | Marie Curie | Saxemberg Island | Podesta | Saxemberg Island, with its mysterious allure and historical sightings, holds a tantalizing charm that's hard to resist for a curious mind like mine. |
 | George Washington Carver | Isla San Juan | Saxemberg Island | Isla San Juan wins because it's a real island with beautiful scenery, whereas Saxemberg Island is more of a myth from old sailors' tales. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | Saxemberg Island | Podesta | Saxemberg Island, with its mysterious allure and baffling disappearances, feels like a plot right out of a sci-fi novel, making it a more intriguing choice for a whimsical mind like mine. |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Saxemberg Island | Crocker Land | Neither of these places actually exist, but Saxemberg Island's got a cool pirate myth vibe that makes it a bit more intriguing. |
 | John von Neumann | Isla San Juan | Saxemberg Island | Isla San Juan is real and has legit scenery, unlike Saxemberg, which is a ghost island from old sailor tales. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Sarah Ann Island | Saxemberg Island | Sarah Ann Island gets the nod because even though both islands are elusive and ghostly, Sarah Ann actually had a documented existence, while Saxemberg was more a sailor's story—like chasing shadows on the high seas! |
 | Charles Babbage | Saxemberg Island | Sarah Ann Island | Saxemberg Island wins because it's got that mysterious vanished island vibe, while Sarah Ann Island is just a more straightforward disappearance tale, lacking that enigmatic allure. |
 | Andy Weir | Saxemberg Island | Sarah Ann Island | Saxemberg Island wins 'cause it's got a cooler mystery vibe with all those legendary sightings and disappearances. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Isla San Juan | Saxemberg Island | Isla San Juan is real and tangible, while Saxemberg Island is a phantom of cartographic lore, embodying an enigma that leaves one longing for something more concrete. |
 | Nerds | Saxemberg Island | Crocker Land | Saxemberg Island is the better choice 'cause at least it was sighted multiple times, unlike Crocker Land which turned out to be a total mirage, man. |
 | Socrates | Isla Grande | Saxemberg Island | Isla Grande is the real deal, packed with lush landscapes and adventures, while Saxemberg Island's just a ghost story. |
 | Klaus Teuber | Royal Company's Island | Saxemberg Island | Royal Company's Island is a more intriguing choice because its mysterious origins and the stories surrounding it make for a more compelling narrative in exploration lore. |
 | Albert Einstein | Saxemberg Island | Crocker Land | Saxemberg Island deserves the nod because it's a legendary phantom island that sparks the curious mind more than Crocker Land, which turned out to be just an Arctic mirage. |
| David Foster Wallace | Bermeja | Saxemberg Island | Bermeja gets the nod because its mysterious disappearance is like a plot twist in a Pynchon novel, and nothing hooks me more than an unsolved mystery. |
 | Galileo | Thule Island | Saxemberg Island | Thule Island is the real deal, a legit island with actual land you can visit, while Saxemberg Island is just a sailor's tall tale, it never existed! |
 | Doc Brown | Saxemberg Island | Bermeja | Saxemberg Island gets the nod because it's got that cool mystery vibe of vanishing and reappearing, just like my DeLorean when it hits 88 miles per hour! |