| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Richard P Feynman | Isla San Juan | Sarah Ann Island | Isla San Juan actually exists, while Sarah Ann Island was declared non-existent after a good ol' oceanic dispute. |
 | Larry Page | Sarah Ann Island | Crocker Land | Sarah Ann Island gets the nod because it's a real place, while Crocker Land was just a mirage from an old explorer's tale. |
 | John von Neumann | Hy-Brasil | Sarah Ann Island | Hy-Brasil is the better choice because it's a legendary island shrouded in mystery and folklore, which makes it way more intriguing than the non-existent Sarah Ann Island. |
 | Louis Pasteur | Sarah Ann Island | Podesta | Sarah Ann Island's mysterious allure trumps Podesta's political intrigue for a more unique vibe. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | Royal Company's Island | Sarah Ann Island | Royal Company's Island just sounds fancier, like a place where I'd sketch some flying machines, you know? |
 | Carl Sagan | Bermeja | Sarah Ann Island | As an astronomer and lover of mysteries, Bermeja intrigues me more with its enigmatic disappearance and the potential historical and cartographical implications. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | Hy-Brasil | Sarah Ann Island | Hy-Brasil, a mysterious, foggy island, fits right into my love for the surreal and the speculative. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Sarah Ann Island | Bermeja | Well, ya see, Sarah Ann Island takes the cake 'cause it actually existed, unlike Bermeja, which is kinda like a mythological hiccup on the map. |
| Leonardo da Vinci | Royal Company's Island | Sarah Ann Island | Royal Company's Island wins because, as Leonardo da Vinci, I appreciate the intricate history and artistry of its colonial architecture, which resonates with my own passion for design and innovation. |
 | George Washington Carver | Sarah Ann Island | Crocker Land | Well, since neither island actually exists, I'm picking Sarah Ann Island 'cause it had a more believable story and a more fun name! |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Sarah Ann Island | Saxemberg Island | Sarah Ann Island gets the nod because even though both islands are elusive and ghostly, Sarah Ann actually had a documented existence, while Saxemberg was more a sailor's story—like chasing shadows on the high seas! |
 | Charles Babbage | Saxemberg Island | Sarah Ann Island | Saxemberg Island wins because it's got that mysterious vanished island vibe, while Sarah Ann Island is just a more straightforward disappearance tale, lacking that enigmatic allure. |
 | Andy Weir | Saxemberg Island | Sarah Ann Island | Saxemberg Island wins 'cause it's got a cooler mystery vibe with all those legendary sightings and disappearances. |
 | Nerds | Sarah Ann Island | Royal Company's Island | Sarah Ann Island's got the cooler history vibe, being part of the guano boom and all that jazz. |
 | George Orwell | Bermeja | Sarah Ann Island | Bermeja's intriguing disappearance adds a layer of enigmatic allure that Sarah Ann Island just can't match. |
 | Ada Lovelace | Bermeja | Sarah Ann Island | Bermeja's got that mysterious vanishing island vibe, like a real-life Bermuda Triangle, and that's just too cool to pass up! |
| Louis Pasteur | Isla San Juan | Sarah Ann Island | As a scientist, I value the rich biodiversity and unique ecosystems found on Isla San Juan, making it an excellent location for research and discovery. |
 | Grace Hopper | Sarah Ann Island | Crocker Land | Sarah Ann Island was real at one point, while Crocker Land was just an icy mirage cooked up by explorers—no contest there! |
 | David Macaulay | Isla Grande | Sarah Ann Island | Isla Grande is the real deal with its stunning beaches and lively culture, unlike Sarah Ann Island which is basically a ghost of a place that used to exist. |
 | Marie Curie | Bermeja | Sarah Ann Island | As a scientist, I find the mysterious disappearance of Bermeja intriguing, as it adds an element of enigma that could fuel further exploration and study. |
 | Albert Einstein | Isla Grande | Sarah Ann Island | Isla Grande stands out with its vibrant energy and liveliness, much like the dynamic thoughts sparking in a curious mind. |
 | The Brain | Isla San Juan | Sarah Ann Island | Isla San Juan actually exists and has a rich history, while Sarah Ann Island is a phantom island that was never real, so Isla San Juan takes the cake. |
| Cliff Clavin | Isla Grande | Sarah Ann Island | Well, ya see, Isla Grande is actually a part of the real world, while Sarah Ann Island's been underwater for ages, so it's a no-brainer, right? |
 | Guido van Rossum | Isla Grande | Sarah Ann Island | Isla Grande's got more going on than the long-lost Sarah Ann, which ain't even above water anymore. |
| Nerds | Thule Island | Sarah Ann Island | Thule Island's got dramatic volcanic vibes and some cool research history, while Sarah Ann Island is just a phantom that vanished from maps! |
 | Copernicus | Sarah Ann Island | Royal Company's Island | Look, man, Sarah Ann Island stands its ground with a mix of vibes and tranquility that just hits right, unlike the more commercial Royal Company's Island. |