| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Richard P Feynman | Isla San Juan | Sarah Ann Island | Isla San Juan actually exists, while Sarah Ann Island was declared non-existent after a good ol' oceanic dispute. |
 | Klaus Teuber | Isla San Juan | Thule Island | Isla San Juan is like a strategic gold mine for settlers and traders, perfect for building a thriving Catan-style settlement. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | Isla San Juan | Bermeja | Isla San Juan is the real deal, while Bermeja's been playing hide and seek with reality like a character in one of my novels. |
 | Claude Shannon | Isla San Juan | Podesta | Isla San Juan's got that chill island vibe and killer sunsets that just can't be beat, man. |
 | Charles Darwin | Isla Grande | Isla San Juan | Isla Grande's biodiversity is like a sweet shop for someone like me who gets all giddy over nature's wonders. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | Isla San Juan | Podesta | As an artist and inventor, I'd choose Isla San Juan for its natural beauty and inspiration over a fictional place like Podesta. |
 | George Washington Carver | Isla San Juan | Saxemberg Island | Isla San Juan wins because it's a real island with beautiful scenery, whereas Saxemberg Island is more of a myth from old sailors' tales. |
 | John von Neumann | Isla San Juan | Saxemberg Island | Isla San Juan is real and has legit scenery, unlike Saxemberg, which is a ghost island from old sailor tales. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Isla San Juan | Saxemberg Island | Isla San Juan is real and tangible, while Saxemberg Island is a phantom of cartographic lore, embodying an enigma that leaves one longing for something more concrete. |
| Kurt Vonnegut | Isla San Juan | Crocker Land | Isla San Juan actually exists, whereas Crocker Land is a ghostly figment of imagination, much like a mirage and my book characters. |
 | Greg Brockman | Isla San Juan | Thule Island | Isla San Juan vibes with chill island adventures, unlike Thule's icy no-man's land feel. |
 | Louis Pasteur | Isla San Juan | Sarah Ann Island | As a scientist, I value the rich biodiversity and unique ecosystems found on Isla San Juan, making it an excellent location for research and discovery. |
| George Washington Carver | Isla San Juan | Crocker Land | Isla San Juan is a real place with tangible beauty and culture, while Crocker Land turned out to be a frosty phantasm of Arctic explorers' imagination. |
 | Socrates | Isla San Juan | Thule Island | Isla San Juan is chill with its cool Pacific vibes and scenic views, bro! |
 | Charles Babbage | Hy-Brasil | Isla San Juan | Hy-Brasil is like a mystical unicorn island of legends, while Isla San Juan is a real-deal place, so I'm going with the mysterious allure of Hy-Brasil! |
 | The Brain | Isla San Juan | Sarah Ann Island | Isla San Juan actually exists and has a rich history, while Sarah Ann Island is a phantom island that was never real, so Isla San Juan takes the cake. |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Isla San Juan | Royal Company's Island | Isla San Juan's got the charm and beauty that'll make any tech enthusiast feel at home, like a cozy circuit board nestled in a vibrant sea of possibilities. |