| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Professor Farnsworth | Isla Grande | Hy-Brasil | Good news, everyone! Isla Grande is real and not just a mythical island like Hy-Brasil, making it the practical choice! |
 | Charles Darwin | Isla Grande | Saxemberg Island | Isla Grande is real and bustling with life, while Saxemberg Island is just a mysterious ghost of sailor tales. |
 | Ada Lovelace | Isla Grande | Hy-Brasil | Isla Grande is real and offers stunning beaches and lush rainforests, whereas Hy-Brasil is just a mythical island that only exists in tales. |
| Charles Darwin | Isla Grande | Isla San Juan | Isla Grande's biodiversity is like a sweet shop for someone like me who gets all giddy over nature's wonders. |
 | Marie Curie | Isla Grande | Hy-Brasil | Isla Grande is real, and I prefer my islands not to be imaginary, merci beaucoup! |
 | Steve Wozniak | Isla Grande | Bermeja | Isla Grande wins because it's a real place you can actually visit, unlike the mysterious and possibly mythical Bermeja. |
 | Doogie Howser | Isla Grande | Crocker Land | Isla Grande is real and ready to party, while Crocker Land is just a ghost of an explorer's dream. |
 | Klaus Teuber | Isla Grande | Royal Company's Island | Isla Grande's got that classic, strategic Catan vibe that makes every game a fresh adventure. |
 | David Macaulay | Isla Grande | Sarah Ann Island | Isla Grande is the real deal with its stunning beaches and lively culture, unlike Sarah Ann Island which is basically a ghost of a place that used to exist. |
 | Socrates | Isla Grande | Saxemberg Island | Isla Grande is the real deal, packed with lush landscapes and adventures, while Saxemberg Island's just a ghost story. |
 | Nerds | Isla Grande | Crocker Land | Isla Grande is a real place you can actually visit and chill out, while Crocker Land is just some mythical land that turned out to be a big ole' Arctic mirage. |
 | Albert Einstein | Isla Grande | Sarah Ann Island | Isla Grande stands out with its vibrant energy and liveliness, much like the dynamic thoughts sparking in a curious mind. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Isla Grande | Sarah Ann Island | Well, ya see, Isla Grande is actually a part of the real world, while Sarah Ann Island's been underwater for ages, so it's a no-brainer, right? |
 | Guido van Rossum | Isla Grande | Sarah Ann Island | Isla Grande's got more going on than the long-lost Sarah Ann, which ain't even above water anymore. |
| Charles Darwin | Isla Grande | Hy-Brasil | Isla Grande wins because it's a real location where natural selection can be observed, while Hy-Brasil is a myth. |
| Marie Curie | Isla Grande | Royal Company's Island | Isla Grande has a more laid-back vibe, making it the perfect chill spot for unwinding away from the hustle and bustle. |