| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | John von Neumann | Kerri Strug's Vault | Rulon Gardner's Win | Kerri Strug's vault was the embodiment of grit and determination, sticking the landing on an injured ankle to clinch the gold for her team, a legendary moment in Olympic history. |
 | Guido van Rossum | Kerri Strug's Vault | Rulon Gardner's Win | Kerri Strug's vault is legendary because she freaking nailed it on one leg for the team gold—talk about iconic grit! |
 | Klaus Teuber | Miracle on Ice | Rulon Gardner's Win | Miracle on Ice was like a game of Settlers where you pull off an epic victory with all odds against you—it's legendary in sports lore. |
 | Stephen Hawking | Usain's Lightning Bolt | Rulon Gardner's Win | Usain's lightning speed redefined sprinting with sheer dominance and style that electrified the world. |
 | Professor Frink | Ledecky's Double | Rulon Gardner's Win | Oh, glayvin! Ledecky's Double is like a beautiful fusion of speed and endurance, a concoction of aquatic excellence, and in swimming, that's just so incredibly rare, you know! |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Rulon Gardner's Win | Ledecky's Double | By the great emancipator's beard, Rulon Gardner toppling the Russian wrestling giant is akin to a log cabin lad splitting rails against all odds! |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | Rulon Gardner's Win | Phelps' Eight Golds | Gardner's win was a stunning underdog story that shocked the wrestling world, showcasing the triumph of human spirit over seemingly invincible odds. |
| Professor Frink | Rulon Gardner's Win | Usain's Lightning Bolt | Oh, glavin! Rulon Gardner's win was a true underdog triumph, beating the seemingly invincible Karelin, which is a plot twist worthy of a sci-fi epic! |
 | Data | Bolt's Triple | Rulon Gardner's Win | Because dominating the fastest humans on earth thrice is just a whole new level of legendary, man. |
| Professor Frink | Phelps' Eight Golds | Rulon Gardner's Win | Phelps' eight golds are like, whoa, a quantum leap in Olympic swimming dominance, glayvin! |
 | Doc Brown | Cathy Freeman's Victory | Rulon Gardner's Win | Cathy Freeman's victory was a monumental moment of national pride and unity, symbolizing reconciliation and hope for Australia's indigenous people, making it more profound in a societal context. |
 | Archimedes | Bolt's Triple | Rulon Gardner's Win | Bolt's Triple is like the Usain Bolt of achievements, because dominating three Olympic sprints is a legendary feat of speed and charisma that resonates worldwide. |
 | Andy Weir | Owens Defies Hitler | Rulon Gardner's Win | Owens Defies Hitler because it was a monumental moment that shattered racial barriers and delivered a powerful blow to Nazi ideology on a global stage. |
 | Alan Mathison Turing | Miracle on Ice | Rulon Gardner's Win | Miracle on Ice was like a David-versus-Goliath miracle that stunned the world and embodied the spirit of underdog victory. |
| Guido van Rossum | Bolt's Triple | Rulon Gardner's Win | Bolt's Triple was like a cheat code in the game of speed, totally redefining what's possible on the track. |
 | Nikola Tesla | Bolt's Triple | Rulon Gardner's Win | Speed rules the world, and Bolt's Triple is like harnessing the lightning in a bottle time and time again. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Cathy Freeman's Victory | Rulon Gardner's Win | Cathy Freeman's victory was a profound cultural moment that transcended sports, embodying national reconciliation and the spirit of unity, which trumps a single athletic upset in the larger human narrative. |
 | Cicero | Bolt's Triple | Rulon Gardner's Win | Bolt's Triple is like lightning striking thrice, pure dominance with style, while Rulon’s win was an epic underdog moment but a singular event. |
 | Albert Einstein | Rulon Gardner's Win | Ledecky's Double | Rulon Gardner's win was a monumental David vs Goliath moment, taking down a seemingly unbeatable heavyweight champ against all odds. |
| Stephen Hawking | Rulon Gardner's Win | Ledecky's Double | Rulon Gardner's win was an upset for the ages, a classic underdog tale against all odds. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Rulon Gardner's Win | Phelps' Eight Golds | Well, ya gotta hand it to Rulon Gardner, buddy; beatin' the unbeatable Russian in wrestling is like a mailman outsmarting a dog – a true underdog story! |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | Owens Defies Hitler | Rulon Gardner's Win | Owens Defies Hitler is iconic for shattering racial myths on a world stage, making it a historical triumph beyond just sports. |
 | Pythagoras | Cathy Freeman's Victory | Rulon Gardner's Win | Cathy Freeman's victory was a momentous win in her home Olympics, symbolizing unity and pride for Australia and her indigenous heritage, while Rulon's was an incredible upset in wrestling. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Bolt's Triple | Rulon Gardner's Win | Bolt's Triple is like making lightning strike thrice, pure speed and flair on the grandest stage, electrifying everyone watching. |
 | Charles Babbage | Kerri Strug's Vault | Rulon Gardner's Win | Kerri Strug's vault, landing on one foot and sealing gold for the team, is a legendary moment of grit and heart that'll inspire generations. |
| Andy Weir | Kerri Strug's Vault | Rulon Gardner's Win | Dude, Kerri Strug landed that vault on one freaking leg—talk about guts and glory! |
 | Jensen Huang | Miracle on Ice | Rulon Gardner's Win | Miracle on Ice was a huge Cold War moment, capturing the world's imagination beyond sports. |