| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Klaus Teuber | Atlantis Lost City | Mary Celeste | As the creator of Catan, I'm all about legendary places and grand adventures, and Atlantis Lost City has fueled imaginations with epic tales for centuries. |
 | Cicero | Mary Celeste | Flight MH370 | I gotta go with Mary Celeste, 'cause the whole crew vanished without a trace, leaving behind an eerily intact ship, just straight up ghost ship vibes, man. |
 | The Brain | Deep Sea Creatures | Mary Celeste | Deep Sea Creatures win because they're like the aliens of our own planet, mysterious and freaky, and who doesn't love a good mystery with some tentacles? |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Mary Celeste | Baltic Sea Anomaly | Mary Celeste is a classic maritime mystery that tickles our imagination more than any alien artifact under the sea. |
 | David Macaulay | Atlantis Lost City | Mary Celeste | Atlantis Lost City is like the ultimate enigma with its mythical allure and grandiose mystery, making it the cooler choice of the two. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | USS Scorpion | Mary Celeste | Great Scott! The USS Scorpion was a nuclear submarine, making it far more futuristic and interesting than the old schooner Mary Celeste. |
 | Louis Pasteur | Atlantis Lost City | Mary Celeste | As a scientist intrigued by mysteries and legends, the grandeur and legend of Atlantis Lost City captivate my curiosity more than the maritime enigma of Mary Celeste. |
 | Marie Curie | Mary Celeste | Baltic Sea Anomaly | As a scientist, the mystery of the Mary Celeste intrigues me more because it offers a tangible historical puzzle with human elements and unanswered questions that ignite curiosity and scientific inquiry. |
 | Professor Frink | Amelia Earhart Disappearance | Mary Celeste | Oh, glayvin! Amelia Earhart's disappearance is the ultimate mystery because it combines aviation adventure with the question of 'Where in the world did she go?' |
 | Belle | Deep Sea Creatures | Mary Celeste | Deep sea creatures are alive and mysterious, while the Mary Celeste is just a ghost ship story. |
 | Linus Torvalds | Mary Celeste | Yonaguni Monument | The Mary Celeste is like an unsolved bug in the code of history, sparking curiosity and theories, just like a mysterious kernel panic. |
 | Buckminster Fuller | Mary Celeste | Yonaguni Monument | Mary Celeste is the seas' mysterious ace, a ghost ship legend sparking curiosity and wonder about human ingenuity and mystery. |
 | Carl Sagan | Atlantis Lost City | Mary Celeste | The Atlantis Lost City enchants with its cosmic allure of mystery and speculative history, inviting us to ponder the wonders of the universe and our place within it. |
 | Nerds | Amelia Earhart Disappearance | Mary Celeste | Amelia Earhart's disappearance is a legendary mystery with an adventurous twist that trumps the ghost ship vibes of the Mary Celeste. |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | Vasa Shipwreck | Mary Celeste | Mate, the Vasa Shipwreck is like a time capsule from the 1600s and gives us wicked insights into shipbuilding and life back then, whereas the Mary Celeste is more of a mystery with less historical goodies. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Amelia Earhart Disappearance | Mary Celeste | Well, ya see, the Amelia Earhart disappearance is a real humdinger because it's got all the intrigue and mystery of aviation history wrapped up in one, unlike the Mary Celeste, which is a maritime mystery but doesn't have that same pioneering spirit. |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Vasa Shipwreck | Mary Celeste | Vasa's epic fail of a maiden voyage makes for a killer story of ambition and shipbuilding gone wrong. |
| Nerds | Mary Celeste | Baltic Sea Anomaly | The Mary Celeste is a classic maritime mystery with real historical intrigue, while the Baltic Sea Anomaly just feels like a blurry YouTube video waiting to happen. |
 | Doogie Howser | Bermuda Triangle | Mary Celeste | Dude, the Bermuda Triangle's got mad mystery vibes with a whole region spooking pilots and sailors for centuries, way more legendary than just one ghost ship. |
 | John von Neumann | Mary Celeste | Yonaguni Monument | The Mary Celeste's eerie story of an abandoned ship at sea out-weirds the mysterious, but less dramatic, underwater Yonaguni Monument. |
 | Andy Weir | Deep Sea Creatures | Mary Celeste | Deep sea creatures are the ultimate undersea badasses, surviving in the darkest, most intense environments on Earth, while the Mary Celeste is just a spooky old ship with a mystery that's never been solved. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Bermuda Triangle | Mary Celeste | The Bermuda Triangle is like a mystery wrapped in an enigma, with countless tales of disappearing ships and planes, making it the heavyweight champ of maritime mysteries compared to the lone ghost ship story of the Mary Celeste. |