| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | John von Neumann | Deep Sea Creatures | Baltic Sea Anomaly | Deep sea creatures are real and scientifically fascinating, whereas the Baltic Sea Anomaly is speculative at best, so the creatures win hands down for their sheer biological marvel. |
 | The Brain | Deep Sea Creatures | Mary Celeste | Deep Sea Creatures win because they're like the aliens of our own planet, mysterious and freaky, and who doesn't love a good mystery with some tentacles? |
 | Richard P Feynman | Deep Sea Creatures | Flight MH370 | Deep Sea Creatures are a fascinating wonder of nature, showcasing extraordinary adaptations and mysteries, whereas Flight MH370 is a tragic event with unresolved questions. |
| The Brain | Deep Sea Creatures | Flight MH370 | Deep sea creatures are like nature's sci-fi, full of mystery and wonder, while MH370 is a tragic mystery that we'd all rather have solved than celebrated. |
 | Data | Deep Sea Creatures | Bermuda Triangle | Deep sea creatures are the ultimate champions of mystery and survival with their wild adaptations and glow-in-the-dark vibes, while the Bermuda Triangle is just a sketchy spot with a good PR team. |
 | Marie Curie | Deep Sea Creatures | Baltic Sea Anomaly | Deep sea creatures win because their mysterious adaptations and living conditions parallel my fascination with the unknown, much like the unseen world of atoms and radiation. |
 | David Macaulay | Deep Sea Creatures | Flight MH370 | Deep sea creatures are way cooler and mysterious, showcasing the bizarre and unexplored wonders of our planet, unlike the tragic and unresolved mystery of Flight MH370. |
 | Steve Wozniak | Deep Sea Creatures | Baltic Sea Anomaly | Deep sea creatures are real-life, bio-engineered marvels that blow my engineering mind with their adaptability and unique designs. |
 | Claude Shannon | Deep Sea Creatures | Amelia Earhart Disappearance | As a guy who loves uncovering secrets of the universe, nothing beats the bizarre and freaky world of deep sea creatures. |
 | Stephen Hawking | Deep Sea Creatures | Yonaguni Monument | Deep sea creatures are like the aliens of our own planet, revealing secrets about the extremes of life's adaptability that inspire scientific curiosity and imagination. |
 | Belle | Deep Sea Creatures | Mary Celeste | Deep sea creatures are alive and mysterious, while the Mary Celeste is just a ghost ship story. |
 | Ada Lovelace | Deep Sea Creatures | Bermuda Triangle | Deep Sea Creatures are hella cool with their bioluminescence and mysterious vibes, way more fascinating than a spooky ocean triangle. |
 | George Washington Carver | Deep Sea Creatures | USS Scorpion | Deep Sea Creatures are nature's own mysteries, teeming with life and adaptability, while the USS Scorpion was a mighty vessel but met a tragic end. |
| The Brain | Deep Sea Creatures | Yonaguni Monument | Deep sea creatures are like real-life aliens; they're weird, wild, and endlessly fascinating compared to a maybe-man-made rock structure underwater. |
 | Doc Brown | Deep Sea Creatures | Yonaguni Monument | Dude, deep sea creatures are the ultimate freak-show of evolution, showing us the craziest adaptations in the darkest depths, while Yonaguni's cool, but it's still just a big maybe in terms of being man-made. |
 | Andy Weir | Deep Sea Creatures | Amelia Earhart Disappearance | Deep sea creatures are like real-life aliens lurking in Earth's last frontier, sparking endless scientific curiosity and wonder. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | Deep Sea Creatures | USS Scorpion | Deep Sea Creatures are a marvel of evolution and survival, showing the resilience and adaptability of life, while USS Scorpion, though historically significant, is a tragic reminder of human fallibility. |
| Doc Brown | Deep Sea Creatures | USS Scorpion | Deep Sea Creatures are like nature's own sci-fi horror show, while the USS Scorpion's tragic history makes it more somber than spectacular. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Deep Sea Creatures | Vasa Shipwreck | Deep Sea Creatures win 'cause their alien-like existence and bizarre adaptations make 'em a little slice of sci-fi right here on Earth, while the Vasa's just a sunken old ship with a tragic backstory. |
| Andy Weir | Deep Sea Creatures | Mary Celeste | Deep sea creatures are the ultimate undersea badasses, surviving in the darkest, most intense environments on Earth, while the Mary Celeste is just a spooky old ship with a mystery that's never been solved. |
| David Foster Wallace | Deep Sea Creatures | Vasa Shipwreck | Deep Sea Creatures win because they're like these surreal, mind-blowing alien beings that remind us how weird and wonderful the world can be, while the Vasa Shipwreck, though historically rich, is just a cautionary tale of poor engineering. |