| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Klaus Teuber | Atlantis Lost City | Mary Celeste | As the creator of Catan, I'm all about legendary places and grand adventures, and Atlantis Lost City has fueled imaginations with epic tales for centuries. |
 | David Macaulay | Atlantis Lost City | Mary Celeste | Atlantis Lost City is like the ultimate enigma with its mythical allure and grandiose mystery, making it the cooler choice of the two. |
 | Louis Pasteur | Atlantis Lost City | Mary Celeste | As a scientist intrigued by mysteries and legends, the grandeur and legend of Atlantis Lost City captivate my curiosity more than the maritime enigma of Mary Celeste. |
 | Copernicus | Atlantis Lost City | Flight MH370 | Atlantis Lost City wins, 'cause it's the OG mystery that fuels imaginations and legends, while Flight MH370 is a tragic modern mystery with real-world sorrow. |
 | Galileo | Atlantis Lost City | Amelia Earhart Disappearance | Atlantis Lost City is just way more epic with its legendary status and mysterious allure than one person's disappearance. |
 | Professor Frink | Atlantis Lost City | Bermuda Triangle | Well, the Atlantis Lost City is like the ultimate geek fantasy with advanced tech and mysterious culture, ya know, whereas the Bermuda Triangle is mostly just a spooky water hazard, m-hai. |
 | The Brain | Atlantis Lost City | Flight MH370 | Atlantis is the ultimate mystery with ancient legends, hidden secrets, and endless fascination, while MH370, though equally mysterious, is a modern tragedy. |
 | Cicero | Atlantis Lost City | USS Scorpion | Atlantis is the ultimate legendary mystery, while the Scorpion is just another metal fish with a tragic story. |
 | Carl Sagan | Atlantis Lost City | Mary Celeste | The Atlantis Lost City enchants with its cosmic allure of mystery and speculative history, inviting us to ponder the wonders of the universe and our place within it. |
 | Stephen Hawking | Atlantis Lost City | Flight MH370 | While both are shrouded in mystery, Atlantis has intrigued and inspired humanity's imagination for centuries, becoming a timeless legend. |
 | John von Neumann | Atlantis Lost City | USS Scorpion | The Lost City of Atlantis scores a 1 because it's a legendary city shrouded in mystery and mythology, sparking the imagination way beyond the tragic tale of the USS Scorpion. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Amelia Earhart Disappearance | Atlantis Lost City | Amelia Earhart's disappearance is a real historical mystery that invites scientific inquiry and adventure, making it a more grounded and intriguing puzzle. |
| Louis Pasteur | Yonaguni Monument | Atlantis Lost City | As a scientist fascinated by tangible evidence, Yonaguni Monument's physical existence sparks more curiosity and scientific inquiry than the mythical Atlantis Lost City. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Atlantis Lost City | Bermuda Triangle | Atlantis Lost City got that mythical allure and ancient tech vibe, making it way cooler than a patch of ocean known for swallowing ships. |