| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | George Washington Carver | Jane Eyre | The Great Gatsby | Being a man of science and character, I'd say Jane Eyre wins for its exploration of independence and moral integrity. |
 | Linus Torvalds | The Odyssey | The Great Gatsby | The Odyssey is like the ultimate kernel of storytelling, with epic adventures and timeless themes that have inspired countless narratives. |
 | Alan Mathison Turing | Pride and Prejudice | The Great Gatsby | Pride and Prejudice captures the complexity of human relationships and social dynamics with timeless wit that just hits different. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | Great Expectations | The Great Gatsby | Good news, everyone! I have chosen 'Great Expectations' because it combines Dickens' intricate storytelling and social critique with a dash of personal growth and redemption that's simply delightful! |
 | Pliny the Elder | Jane Eyre | The Great Gatsby | Jane Eyre's got that fierce independence and depth that just hits different, making it a timeless classic that refuses to be overlooked. |
 | Steve Wozniak | The Great Gatsby | Jane Eyre | The Great Gatsby wins because its exploration of the American Dream and the Jazz Age's glitz fits my interest in societal impact like a well-coded program. |
| Pliny the Elder | Wuthering Heights | The Great Gatsby | Wuthering Heights wins because its intense emotions and dark, gothic vibes make it a more gripping read for those who dig the drama and complex characters. |
 | Belle | War and Peace | The Great Gatsby | War and Peace is like this epic saga of history, philosophy, and human nature all mashed into one gigantic masterpiece! |
 | Pythagoras | Crime and Punishment | The Great Gatsby | Dostoevsky's deep dive into the human psyche and moral dilemmas hits harder than Gatsby's party scene. |
 | George Orwell | Moby Dick | The Great Gatsby | Moby Dick's epic narrative and profound exploration of humanity's struggle against nature resonate more with my fondness for complex societal reflections. |
 | Alex Trebek | Crime and Punishment | The Great Gatsby | Crime and Punishment digs deep into the human psyche with a gritty exploration of morality and redemption, while The Great Gatsby is more about glitzy decadence and the American Dream. |
 | Charles Babbage | Pride and Prejudice | The Great Gatsby | Pride and Prejudice takes the cake 'cause Jane Austen's wit and exploration of social mores still resonate with the same elegance and depth that charms readers across centuries. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Great Expectations | The Great Gatsby | Great Expectations gets the edge with its deep exploration of character development and societal critique that tickles my analytical fancy. |
 | Claude Shannon | Jane Eyre | The Great Gatsby | As a pioneering figure in information theory, I'd appreciate the complex character development in Jane Eyre over the symbolic narrative of The Great Gatsby. |