| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Nerds | Crime and Punishment | Pride and Prejudice | Crime and Punishment dives deep into the mind, wrestling with guilt and redemption in a way that hits different for those who dig psychological drama. |
 | Data | Crime and Punishment | Moby Dick | Crime and Punishment dives deep into the psychological turmoil of guilt and redemption, giving you the kind of mind-bending experience that's hard to shake off. |
 | Antoine Lavoisier | Crime and Punishment | Jane Eyre | Crime and Punishment really digs deep into the human psyche and moral dilemmas, which aligns with my scientific curiosity about what drives human behavior. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Crime and Punishment | 1984 | Because Dostoevsky digs into the gnarly depths of the human psyche in a way that's just soul-crushingly profound, man. |
| Antoine Lavoisier | Crime and Punishment | Jane Eyre | Crime and Punishment digs deep into the human psyche and moral dilemmas, which resonates with my scientific curiosity about the nature of humanity. |
 | Ada Lovelace | Crime and Punishment | Jane Eyre | Crime and Punishment dives deep into the psychological chaos and moral dilemmas, making it an intense ride through the human psyche. |
| Data | Crime and Punishment | The Odyssey | I'm picking Crime and Punishment because Dostoevsky dives deep into the human psyche, making you feel like a fly on the wall of Raskolnikov's chaotic mind. |
 | Doc Brown | Crime and Punishment | 1984 | Great Scott! Crime and Punishment dives deep into the human psyche in a way that's truly timeless, even if 1984 is a dystopian classic. |
 | George Orwell | Crime and Punishment | Pride and Prejudice | Crime and Punishment delves into the psychological depths of guilt and redemption, a theme that resonates with the exploration of totalitarianism and human nature in my own works. |
 | Neal Stephenson | Crime and Punishment | Jane Eyre | Crime and Punishment dives into the gnarly depths of human psyche and existential dread with a complexity that's just my jam. |
 | Charles Darwin | Crime and Punishment | Wuthering Heights | As a naturalist and a fan of exploring the complexities of the human condition, I'd say Crime and Punishment wins for its deep psychological exploration and moral dilemmas. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Crime and Punishment | Wuthering Heights | Well, ya know, Crime and Punishment dives deep into the human psyche like a postal inspector with a magnifying glass, whereas Wuthering Heights is more like a windy day in the Boston Commons, all over the place and hard to pin down. |
 | Marie Curie | Crime and Punishment | Moby Dick | While 'Moby Dick' is a classic exploration of obsession and the sea, 'Crime and Punishment' delves deeper into the psychological and moral dilemmas of its characters, something that fascinates a scientist like me who is interested in the complexities of human nature. |
| George Orwell | Crime and Punishment | Jane Eyre | While both novels delve into profound human truths, Crime and Punishment's exploration of guilt and redemption resonates with my own experiences of grappling with societal and personal moralities. |
 | Pythagoras | Crime and Punishment | The Great Gatsby | Dostoevsky's deep dive into the human psyche and moral dilemmas hits harder than Gatsby's party scene. |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Crime and Punishment | Pride and Prejudice | Given my penchant for complex human psychology and moral dilemmas, Crime and Punishment scratches that itch with its deep dive into the mind of a conflicted soul. |
| Pythagoras | Crime and Punishment | Pride and Prejudice | Crime and Punishment delves deep into the complex psyche of human morality and guilt, which resonates with my love for logic and philosophical inquiry. |
| Charles Darwin | Crime and Punishment | 1984 | As a naturalist fascinated by the complexity of human nature, Dostoevsky's deep dive into the moral dilemmas and psychological exploration in Crime and Punishment resonates more with my curiosity about the human condition. |
 | Alex Trebek | Crime and Punishment | The Great Gatsby | Crime and Punishment digs deep into the human psyche with a gritty exploration of morality and redemption, while The Great Gatsby is more about glitzy decadence and the American Dream. |
 | Linus Torvalds | Crime and Punishment | 1984 | Crime and Punishment digs into the gnarly depths of human psychology, which is kinda like debugging a really complex piece of code, compared to 1984's more straightforward dystopian vibes. |
| Data | Crime and Punishment | Pride and Prejudice | Crime and Punishment dives deep into the human psyche and moral dilemmas, offering a richer exploration of existential themes. |