| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Louis Pasteur | Iliad | Aeneid | As a man of science, I appreciate the Iliad's raw and unfiltered glimpse into human nature and ancient warfare's complexities, much like examining a complex microbial world under a microscope. |
 | Pliny the Elder | Iliad | Aeneid | The Iliad is the O.G. epic that laid down the groundwork for all others with its raw intensity and timeless storytelling. |
 | Data | Iliad | Epic of Gilgamesh | The Iliad is like the original blockbuster with epic battles and larger-than-life heroes, making it a timeless classic in storytelling. |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | Journey to the West | Iliad | Journey to the West is a wild ride with epic adventures and spiritual depth, plus it has a monkey king, and who doesn't love a cheeky monkey king? |
 | Stephen Hawking | Odyssey | Iliad | Odyssey is like the ultimate road trip with monsters, magic, and mayhem, making it a wild ride compared to the straight-up war vibes of the Iliad. |
 | Carl Sagan | Iliad | Epic of Gilgamesh | While both are monumental epics, the Iliad's intricate exploration of human nature and the complexities of heroism resonate more deeply with the scientific curiosity of human behavior. |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Iliad | Aeneid | The Iliad's raw power and foundational role in Western literature make it a hard act to follow, even for the esteemed Aeneid. |
 | Pythagoras | Journey to the West | Iliad | Journey to the West is like an epic road trip with magical creatures and hilarious antics, making it a wild ride compared to the Iliad's intense war drama. |
| Pliny the Elder | Iliad | Edda | The Iliad is a timeless epic packed with intense drama and rich characters that have captivated audiences for centuries, showing the power of storytelling in its prime. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | Ramayana | Iliad | Great Scott! The Ramayana is a timeless epic bursting with cosmic adventures and moral wisdom, making it a delight for a futurama nerd like me! |
| Louis Pasteur | Iliad | Aeneid | Dude, the Iliad is the OG epic; it set the stage for all the heroes and battles we still geek out over today. |
 | Alex Trebek | Odyssey | Iliad | Odyssey's got that epic road trip vibe, full of trickster moves and relentless adventure, capturing the imagination in a way that's timeless and thrilling. |