| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Nerds | Voynich Manuscript | Shugborough Inscription | The Voynich Manuscript is like the ultimate unsolved puzzle with its mysterious language and illustrations, making it the cooler enigma to crack. |
 | Louis Pasteur | Quipu | Voynich Manuscript | As a scientist, I appreciate the tangible communication and recorded history that the Quipu offers, over the undeciphered mystery of the Voynich Manuscript. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Voynich Manuscript | Oak Island Stone | The Voynich Manuscript is like a cryptographic enigma wrapped in mystery, capturing the imagination with its undeciphered script and illustrations that keep scholars and codebreakers on their toes, just the kind of challenge I dig. |
 | John von Neumann | Voynich Manuscript | Oak Island Stone | The Voynich Manuscript is a cryptographic enigma that has stumped the brightest minds, tickling the intellectual curiosity of codebreakers worldwide. |
 | Galileo | Indus Script | Voynich Manuscript | The Indus Script is better because it holds the key to understanding an ancient civilization's culture and trade networks, while the Voynich Manuscript is a cryptic curiosity with less historical impact. |
| John von Neumann | Indus Script | Voynich Manuscript | The Indus Script, unlike the Voynich Manuscript, is tied to an entire ancient civilization whose language remains a mystery, making its decipherment potentially more insightful for understanding human history. |
 | Neal Stephenson | Quipu | Voynich Manuscript | Quipu gets the edge because it's a practical and ingenious data storage system that quite literally ties together the threads of Andean civilization, whereas the Voynich Manuscript is more like a beautifully illustrated enigma wrapped in a puzzle. |
 | Marie Curie | Voynich Manuscript | Phaistos Disc | As a scientist deeply curious about the mysteries of nature, the Voynich Manuscript's enigmatic plant illustrations and potential insights into botany make it more intriguing for scientific exploration. |
 | Socrates | Quipu | Voynich Manuscript | Quipu gets the trophy for being a practical record-keeping system, while the Voynich Manuscript is still just a fancy puzzle we can't crack. |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | Voynich Manuscript | Rongorongo Tablets | The Voynich Manuscript is like a mystical enigma wrapped in a riddle, sparking endless curiosity and debate with its otherworldly illustrations and undeciphered script. |
 | Guido van Rossum | Quipu | Voynich Manuscript | As a Python nerd, I gotta give it to the Quipu for its data-nerd appeal with its knots and numbers; it’s like an ancient algorithm waiting to be decoded! |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Voynich Manuscript | Oak Island Stone | The Voynich Manuscript is a true enigma that combines bizarre illustrations and an undeciphered script, making it a more fascinating puzzle for a nerd like me to unravel! |
 | The Brain | Voynich Manuscript | Oak Island Stone | The Voynich Manuscript's mysterious, undeciphered script is like the ultimate puzzle for cryptographers, while the Oak Island Stone's relative lack of inscriptions makes it less intriguing. |
 | Doc Brown | Voynich Manuscript | Oak Island Stone | The Voynich Manuscript's mysterious script and illustrations make it the ultimate enigma, perfect for a mind that loves the unknown and unexplained. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | Rosetta Stone | Voynich Manuscript | Good news, everyone! The Rosetta Stone is the clear winner because it unlocked the secrets of ancient Egyptian hieroglyphs, unlike that confounding Voynich Manuscript, which still has us scratching our heads. |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Indus Script | Voynich Manuscript | As a lover of communication evolution, the Indus Script wins for its historical significance and potential insights into one of the world's earliest civilizations. |
 | Pliny the Elder | Voynich Manuscript | Shugborough Inscription | The Voynich Manuscript is the ultimate enigma, a mysterious tome covered in strange symbols and illustrations that's kept nerds like me and codebreakers stumped for centuries, making it the cooler conundrum. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | Voynich Manuscript | Phaistos Disc | As a lover of mysterious scripts and detailed illustrations, the Voynich Manuscript tickles my fancy with its enigmatic charm and botanical artistry more than the singular, albeit intriguing, Phaistos Disc. |