| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Klaus Teuber | Phaistos Disc | Kensington Runestone | The Phaistos Disc wins because its mysterious symbols are like an ancient strategy game, challenging us to decode its secrets, much like the intrigue of unraveling a great board game. |
 | Charles Darwin | Phaistos Disc | Kensington Runestone | As the great nerd Charles Darwin, the Phaistos Disc wins for its cryptic script and unsolved origins, much like the mysteries of evolution's path. |
 | Albert Einstein | Phaistos Disc | Shugborough Inscription | As an old-school science guy, the Phaistos Disc's unresolved mystery intrigues me more because it promises an ancient linguistic breakthrough if cracked, like solving a cosmic puzzle! |
 | Andy Weir | Phaistos Disc | Kensington Runestone | The Phaistos Disc is like the OG of mysterious artifacts with its undeciphered script, making it a way cooler enigma than the debated authenticity of the Kensington Runestone. |
 | Nikola Tesla | Rongorongo Tablets | Phaistos Disc | Rongorongo Tablets are a mysterious script with potential insights into the lost knowledge of Easter Island, sparking my boundless curiosity for unraveling the enigmatic codes of the past. |
 | Marie Curie | Voynich Manuscript | Phaistos Disc | As a scientist deeply curious about the mysteries of nature, the Voynich Manuscript's enigmatic plant illustrations and potential insights into botany make it more intriguing for scientific exploration. |
 | Greg Brockman | Quipu | Phaistos Disc | Quipu wins because it was a legit communication tool in the Andes, while the Phaistos Disc is still a mystery wrapped in an enigma. |
 | Galileo | Phaistos Disc | Oak Island Stone | The Phaistos Disc is cooler because it might actually be some lost language or code, while the Oak Island Stone is more of a wild goose chase without much solid backing. |
 | Socrates | Rongorongo Tablets | Phaistos Disc | Rongorongo Tablets have a more extensive collection of inscriptions, offering a bigger mystery for decoding than the solitary Phaistos Disc. |
 | David Macaulay | Quipu | Phaistos Disc | Quipu is the cool ancient calculator that actually helped civilizations thrive, while the Phaistos Disc is more like an enigmatic mystery that just looks pretty. |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | Phaistos Disc | Shugborough Inscription | The Phaistos Disc's ancient mystery is like an age-old enigma that tickles the brain, making it the ultimate puzzle for a history enthusiast like me. |
 | Stephen Hawking | Nazca Lines | Phaistos Disc | The Nazca Lines are way bigger and more mysterious, capturing the imagination in a way the Phaistos Disc just can't match. |
 | Steve Wozniak | Rongorongo Tablets | Phaistos Disc | The Rongorongo Tablets are like the ultimate unsolved puzzle with more potential to reveal secrets about an entire lost language. |
 | Andy Weir | Nazca Lines | Phaistos Disc | The Nazca Lines are like the world's biggest doodle made by aliens (probably not), and that's just too cool to beat. |
 | Archimedes | Phaistos Disc | Rongorongo Tablets | The Phaistos Disc is like the OG, mysterious single artifact that keeps the imagination running wild, while Rongorongo has more pieces but no mic-drop moment. |
 | George Washington Carver | Phaistos Disc | Shugborough Inscription | The Phaistos Disc is like an ancient mystery wrapped in a swirling enigma, with its undeciphered script and unique design, making it an alluring puzzle for the ages. |
 | The Brain | Indus Script | Phaistos Disc | The Indus Script gives us a bigger mystery to solve, with its civilization spanning a vast region and yet remaining undeciphered, it's like the ultimate ancient code challenge! |
 | John von Neumann | Phaistos Disc | Shugborough Inscription | The Phaistos Disc is like the ultimate puzzle because it's an ancient artifact with a mysterious language, making it a cooler challenge for deciphering history. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | Voynich Manuscript | Phaistos Disc | As a lover of mysterious scripts and detailed illustrations, the Voynich Manuscript tickles my fancy with its enigmatic charm and botanical artistry more than the singular, albeit intriguing, Phaistos Disc. |