| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Stephen Hawking | Nazca Lines | Oak Island Stone | The Nazca Lines are like a cosmic canvas scribbled by ancient astronomers, mind-blowing in their scale and mystery. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Voynich Manuscript | Oak Island Stone | The Voynich Manuscript is like a cryptographic enigma wrapped in mystery, capturing the imagination with its undeciphered script and illustrations that keep scholars and codebreakers on their toes, just the kind of challenge I dig. |
 | John von Neumann | Voynich Manuscript | Oak Island Stone | The Voynich Manuscript is a cryptographic enigma that has stumped the brightest minds, tickling the intellectual curiosity of codebreakers worldwide. |
 | Jensen Huang | Nazca Lines | Oak Island Stone | The Nazca Lines are an epic testament to ancient ingenuity, spanning vast tracts of desert with mind-blowing precision and scale. |
 | Andy Weir | Rongorongo Tablets | Oak Island Stone | Rongorongo Tablets win because they're like ancient cosmic puzzles waiting to be cracked, while Oak Island Stone is more like a pirate's tall tale. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Kensington Runestone | Oak Island Stone | The Kensington Runestone, with its blend of linguistic oddities and mysterious origins, offers a more compelling narrative and scholarly intrigue. |
 | Galileo | Phaistos Disc | Oak Island Stone | The Phaistos Disc is cooler because it might actually be some lost language or code, while the Oak Island Stone is more of a wild goose chase without much solid backing. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Voynich Manuscript | Oak Island Stone | The Voynich Manuscript is a true enigma that combines bizarre illustrations and an undeciphered script, making it a more fascinating puzzle for a nerd like me to unravel! |
| John von Neumann | Quipu | Oak Island Stone | Quipu is like the OG data encoding method of the Incas, way cooler than a mystery stone with carvings that we still can't figure out. |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Kensington Runestone | Oak Island Stone | The Kensington Runestone is cooler because it's a mysterious artifact with Viking vibes and has sparked way more debates and intrigue than the Oak Island Stone. |
 | The Brain | Voynich Manuscript | Oak Island Stone | The Voynich Manuscript's mysterious, undeciphered script is like the ultimate puzzle for cryptographers, while the Oak Island Stone's relative lack of inscriptions makes it less intriguing. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Shugborough Inscription | Oak Island Stone | The Shugborough Inscription's mystery blends history and cryptography, a fascinating puzzle for curious minds. |
 | Pythagoras | Kensington Runestone | Oak Island Stone | Kensington Runestone's got that Viking flair and a more compelling story, man! |
 | Data | Rongorongo Tablets | Oak Island Stone | Rongorongo Tablets are straight-up mind-bogglin' relics with potential written language, while the Oak Island Stone is more of a mysterious footnote in treasure lore. |
 | Marie Curie | Rongorongo Tablets | Oak Island Stone | As a scientist and explorer of the unknown, the Rongorongo Tablets intrigue me more with their undeciphered script, offering a fascinating puzzle of an extinct civilization. |
| Andy Weir | Quipu | Oak Island Stone | Quipu is like ancient Incan data storage, way cooler than a maybe treasure map on a stone. |
 | Doc Brown | Voynich Manuscript | Oak Island Stone | The Voynich Manuscript's mysterious script and illustrations make it the ultimate enigma, perfect for a mind that loves the unknown and unexplained. |
 | Charles Babbage | Oak Island Stone | Shugborough Inscription | The Oak Island Stone's mystery invites more curious adventurers and treasure hunters, fueling the imagination like a steampunk contraption gone wild. |
 | Nikola Tesla | Rosetta Stone | Oak Island Stone | As a man of science and discovery, I find the Rosetta Stone more electrifying due to its pivotal role in deciphering ancient languages, sparking a revolution in understanding human history. |
 | Nerds | Rosetta Stone | Oak Island Stone | The Rosetta Stone's crucial role in deciphering Egyptian hieroglyphs trumps the Oak Island Stone's mystery, 'cause let's be real, understanding ancient languages beats a stone with cryptic carvings any day. |
 | Larry Page | Kensington Runestone | Oak Island Stone | The Kensington Runestone's got more historical intrigue and a decent chance of authenticity, unlike Oak Island's mystery that just drags on. |
 | George Orwell | Rosetta Stone | Oak Island Stone | The Rosetta Stone is the linguistic key that unlocked ancient Egypt, while the Oak Island Stone is more of a mysterious curiosity without much to show for it. |