| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Klaus Teuber | Phaistos Disc | Kensington Runestone | The Phaistos Disc wins because its mysterious symbols are like an ancient strategy game, challenging us to decode its secrets, much like the intrigue of unraveling a great board game. |
 | Antoine Lavoisier | Nazca Lines | Kensington Runestone | The Nazca Lines are a mind-blowing ancient masterpiece scratched into the desert that still baffles us today, while the Kensington Runestone is more of a debated curiosity. |
 | Charles Darwin | Phaistos Disc | Kensington Runestone | As the great nerd Charles Darwin, the Phaistos Disc wins for its cryptic script and unsolved origins, much like the mysteries of evolution's path. |
 | Copernicus | Rongorongo Tablets | Kensington Runestone | Rongorongo Tablets are like a cryptic time capsule from a mysterious culture, while the Kensington Runestone is more like a debatable artifact with a Nordic twist - the tablets just got more cool factor. |
 | Andy Weir | Phaistos Disc | Kensington Runestone | The Phaistos Disc is like the OG of mysterious artifacts with its undeciphered script, making it a way cooler enigma than the debated authenticity of the Kensington Runestone. |
 | Steve Wozniak | Kensington Runestone | Shugborough Inscription | The Kensington Runestone is like a mystery wrapped in an enigma, combining history and adventure, just like solving a complex tech problem. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Kensington Runestone | Oak Island Stone | The Kensington Runestone, with its blend of linguistic oddities and mysterious origins, offers a more compelling narrative and scholarly intrigue. |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Kensington Runestone | Oak Island Stone | The Kensington Runestone is cooler because it's a mysterious artifact with Viking vibes and has sparked way more debates and intrigue than the Oak Island Stone. |
 | Doc Brown | Nazca Lines | Kensington Runestone | The Nazca Lines are like a massive outdoor art gallery, etched into the earth by ancient hands, making them an epic mystery and a visual feast from the skies! |
 | Nikola Tesla | Nazca Lines | Kensington Runestone | The Nazca Lines are an engineering marvel from the sky, showcasing ancient ingenuity that resonates with my passion for harnessing natural forces and thinking big. |
 | Pythagoras | Kensington Runestone | Oak Island Stone | Kensington Runestone's got that Viking flair and a more compelling story, man! |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Nazca Lines | Kensington Runestone | The Nazca Lines are a massive, mysterious display that's visible from the skies and boggles the mind with its scale and complexity, making it a mind-blowing feature of ancient human creativity. |
 | Larry Page | Kensington Runestone | Oak Island Stone | The Kensington Runestone's got more historical intrigue and a decent chance of authenticity, unlike Oak Island's mystery that just drags on. |
| Doc Brown | Indus Script | Kensington Runestone | The Indus Script is like this ancient puzzle we still can't crack, making it way cooler in the mystery department. |