| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Data | Treasure of Lima | The Menorah | Treasure of Lima is like the ultimate pirate mystery adventure, whereas The Menorah is more about historical and cultural significance. |
 | George Orwell | Florentine Diamond | Treasure of Lima | The Florentine Diamond, with its storied history and regal allure, shines brighter in the annals of intrigue than the elusive Treasure of Lima. |
 | Archimedes | Crown Jewels | Treasure of Lima | The Crown Jewels have some serious historical bling factor and are still dazzling in real life. |
 | Charles Babbage | Honjo Masamune | Treasure of Lima | As a legendary sword crafted by the famous Japanese swordsmith Masamune, the Honjo Masamune represents unparalleled craftsmanship and historical significance, making it a standout choice for a historical nerd like me. |
 | George Washington Carver | Treasure of Lima | Lost Dutchman's | The Treasure of Lima just sounds like it's dripping with more adventure and mystery, like a dandy tale straight out of a swashbuckling novel! |
 | Doc Brown | Crown Jewels | Treasure of Lima | Great Scott! The Crown Jewels are a symbol of monarchy and historical power, plus they're not lost like the Treasure of Lima! |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Treasure of Lima | Isabella's Necklace | Ah, the Treasure of Lima! Its legendary lore and tantalizing tales make my scientific curiosity tingle more than Isabella's sparkle. |
| Doc Brown | Treasure of Lima | Scepter of Dagobert | Dude, the Treasure of Lima is like a legendary pirate treasure with a mystery that's as wild as time travel itself! |
 | The Brain | Treasure of Lima | Honjo Masamune | I'll take the legendary stash with potential millions over a sword that might just sit pretty in a museum any day. |
 | Louis Pasteur | Honjo Masamune | Treasure of Lima | As someone who treasures craftsmanship and scientific precision, the Honjo Masamune, a masterfully crafted samurai sword, stands out in its historical and artistic significance. |
 | Professor Frink | The Menorah | Treasure of Lima | Well, my glayvin, the Menorah has historical and cultural significance, making it a more profound artifact, m-hay. |
| George Orwell | Treasure of Lima | Florentine Diamond | The Treasure of Lima, shrouded in mystery and tales of pirates, captures the very essence of adventure and rebellion against imperialist forces. |