| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Data | Treasure of Lima | The Menorah | Treasure of Lima is like the ultimate pirate mystery adventure, whereas The Menorah is more about historical and cultural significance. |
 | Archimedes | The Menorah | Scepter of Dagobert | The Menorah’s got ancient vibes and cultural heft that just outshine the Scepter’s royal glitter. |
 | Grace Hopper | Amber Room | The Menorah | The Amber Room, with its dazzling history and mysterious disappearance, is like the rock star of lost treasures. |
 | Steve Wozniak | The Menorah | Peking Man | The Menorah, like tech, is a symbol of innovation and resilience, lighting the way through history. |
 | Professor Frink | The Menorah | Isabella's Necklace | Well, The Menorah's got a richer history and cultural significance, ya know? Glavin! |
 | Nerds | Amber Room | The Menorah | The Amber Room is like the OG legend of lost treasures with its mysterious disappearance and historical intrigue, while The Menorah, though significant, just doesn't have the same enigmatic vibes. |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | The Menorah | Peking Man | The Menorah lights up the world with cultural significance, while Peking Man is just a cool archaelogical find. |
| Archimedes | Florentine Diamond | The Menorah | The Florentine Diamond's rich history and legendary beauty make it a timeless gem worth more than just its carats. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Isabella's Necklace | The Menorah | Isabella's Necklace dazzles with its intricate history and unmatched beauty, making it the clear standout. |
| Grace Hopper | Honjo Masamune | The Menorah | While the Menorah is an enduring symbol of faith and tradition, the Honjo Masamune is a legendary sword reflecting the pinnacle of craftsmanship and historical intrigue, which is undeniably cool. |
 | Marie Curie | Isabella's Necklace | The Menorah | Isabella's Necklace has that extra sparkle that catches the eye and tells a story like no other. |
 | Doc Brown | Florentine Diamond | The Menorah | Great Scott! It's gotta be the Florentine Diamond, with its rich history and stunning yellow color that dazzles the eyes like a flux capacitor on full charge! |
 | John von Neumann | The Menorah | Honjo Masamune | Both are legendary and rich in history, but The Menorah symbolizes enduring faith and tradition across generations. |
 | Nikola Tesla | The Menorah | Scepter of Dagobert | As a lover of illuminating inventions, The Menorah's symbolic light and cultural significance shine brighter in human history than a mere royal scepter. |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | The Menorah | Peking Man | The Menorah's cultural and historical significance shines brighter than Peking Man's archaeological intrigue. |
| Professor Frink | The Menorah | Treasure of Lima | Well, my glayvin, the Menorah has historical and cultural significance, making it a more profound artifact, m-hay. |
| Grace Hopper | Lost Dutchman's | The Menorah | Lost Dutchman's has that rugged charm and killer vibe that just gives it the edge, no contest. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | The Menorah | Scepter of Dagobert | The Menorah's got a light that keeps on shining, a beacon through ages, while the Scepter's just a fancy stick for one man's fleeting power trip. |
 | Larry Page | The Menorah | Scepter of Dagobert | The Menorah wins because its rich cultural significance and historical value outshine the Scepter's royal bling in the grand scheme of human heritage. |