| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Florentine Diamond | Isabella's Necklace | The Florentine Diamond shines with a rich history and legendary tales, making it a fascinating gem for any curious mind. |
 | George Orwell | Peking Man | Florentine Diamond | While the Florentine Diamond is a marvel of wealth and beauty, the Peking Man represents an invaluable key to understanding our shared human history and evolution. |
| Guglielmo Marconi | Florentine Diamond | Lost Dutchman's | The Florentine Diamond's legendary history and unmatched elegance make it the gem that shines the brightest, hands down. |
 | Alan Mathison Turing | Peking Man | Florentine Diamond | Peking Man is an archaeological treasure that gave us insight into early human evolution, while the Florentine Diamond is just a fancy rock. |
 | David Macaulay | Scepter of Dagobert | Florentine Diamond | The Scepter of Dagobert wins 'cause it's a royal artifact with historical swag, while the Florentine Diamond is cool but missing in action. |
 | Carl Sagan | Amber Room | Florentine Diamond | The Amber Room, with its intricate craftsmanship and mysterious history, is like a cosmic wonder that showcases the depth of human artistry and intrigue. |
 | Archimedes | Honjo Masamune | Florentine Diamond | While the Florentine Diamond is a stunning gem with a rich history, the Honjo Masamune is an unparalleled symbol of craftsmanship and samurai legacy, making it the ultimate badass choice. |
 | The Brain | Isabella's Necklace | Florentine Diamond | Isabella's Necklace is way cooler because it's shrouded in mystery and intrigue, while the Florentine Diamond, although historically significant, just doesn't have the same allure. |
| George Orwell | Florentine Diamond | Treasure of Lima | The Florentine Diamond, with its storied history and regal allure, shines brighter in the annals of intrigue than the elusive Treasure of Lima. |
 | Andy Weir | Lost Dutchman's | Florentine Diamond | The Lost Dutchman's is shrouded in mystery and adventure, which makes for a killer story compared to the Florentine Diamond's royal bling history. |
| Archimedes | Florentine Diamond | The Menorah | The Florentine Diamond's rich history and legendary beauty make it a timeless gem worth more than just its carats. |
 | Jensen Huang | Florentine Diamond | Scepter of Dagobert | The Florentine Diamond is a legendary gem with a mysterious past, making it the ultimate treasure for history and luxury buffs. |
 | Professor Frink | Amber Room | Florentine Diamond | Oh, my glayven, the Amber Room is like a legendary lost treasure of craftsmanship and history, while the Florentine Diamond is just a big shiny rock, ya know, so the mystery and artistry totally win out! |
 | Albert Einstein | Florentine Diamond | Lost Dutchman's | The Florentine Diamond's got the history and royal flair that just outshines the mysterious allure of the Lost Dutchman's gold. |
 | Doogie Howser | Florentine Diamond | Isabella's Necklace | The Florentine Diamond's rich history and legendary status make it the ultimate treasure for any collector. |
| Andy Weir | Honjo Masamune | Florentine Diamond | While the Florentine Diamond is a stunning gem, the Honjo Masamune is a legendary sword with historical significance and craftsmanship that's just out of this world, making it cooler in my book. |
| Guglielmo Marconi | Florentine Diamond | Lost Dutchman's | The Florentine Diamond's storied history and legendary beauty make it the crown jewel of enigma and allure. |
 | Doc Brown | Florentine Diamond | The Menorah | Great Scott! It's gotta be the Florentine Diamond, with its rich history and stunning yellow color that dazzles the eyes like a flux capacitor on full charge! |
| Doogie Howser | Scepter of Dagobert | Florentine Diamond | The Scepter of Dagobert's rich history and royal significance make it the cooler choice over a misplaced diamond. |
 | Klaus Teuber | Scepter of Dagobert | Florentine Diamond | As someone who loves crafting epic strategy games, the Scepter of Dagobert, with its rich history and royal flair, feels like it could be a key piece in a game of thrones, adding layers of intrigue and power dynamics. |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | Scepter of Dagobert | Florentine Diamond | The Scepter of Dagobert is steeped in historical significance and royal flair, making it a cooler relic than just another shiny rock. |
| George Orwell | Treasure of Lima | Florentine Diamond | The Treasure of Lima, shrouded in mystery and tales of pirates, captures the very essence of adventure and rebellion against imperialist forces. |