| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Nikola Tesla | Atlantis | Pompeii | Ah, Atlantis! A realm of limitless energy and innovation, much like my dreams of harnessing the Earth's power, surpasses the volcanic fate of Pompeii. |
 | Klaus Teuber | Petra | Atlantis | Petra’s got that real-world charm and mystery that you just can't beat with tales from the deep. |
 | Andy Weir | Atlantis | Pompeii | Atlantis because who doesn't love a legendary city with advanced tech that just up and vanished underwater—talk about mysterious sci-fi vibes! |
 | Professor Frink | Petra | Atlantis | Oh, glavin! While Atlantis is shrouded in mystery and speculative science, Petra is a real archaeological marvel with stunning rock-cut architecture you can actually visit! |
 | George Orwell | Troy | Atlantis | Troy's real-world roots and legendary war stories give it a depth and grit that Atlantis' speculative myth just can't match. |
 | Galileo | Machu Picchu | Atlantis | Machu Picchu's real-life mysteries and breathtaking mountaintop views are way cooler than Atlantis' debatable existence. |
 | Claude Shannon | Atlantis | Vinland | As a fan of mythical civilizations and their legendary tech innovations, Atlantis just has that extra sparkle of intrigue and mystery. |
 | Pliny the Elder | Atlantis | Shangri-La | As a lover of ancient lore and maritime mysteries, Atlantis takes the cake with its epic tale of a lost civilization and the intoxicating allure of its submerged splendor. |
 | Carl Sagan | Pompeii | Atlantis | While Atlantis fascinates with its mystical allure, Pompeii offers a poignant, tangible glimpse into the lives of real people, frozen in time by nature’s dramatic display. |
 | Alex Trebek | Angkor | Atlantis | Angkor is real and it's a stunning testament to human achievement, unlike Atlantis which is just a legendary tale. |
 | Data | Pompeii | Atlantis | Pompeii's real ruins and history are way more lit than Atlantis' mythical vibes. |
 | Copernicus | Shangri-La | Atlantis | Shangri-La's peaceful vibes and timeless wisdom win over Atlantis's watery mystery, hands down! |
 | Buckminster Fuller | Atlantis | El Dorado | Atlantis vibes with my geodesic curiosity, it's where imagination meets ancient tech dreams. |
| Galileo | Atlantis | Vinland | Atlantis wins 'cause it's got that mystical vibe and everyone loves a good mystery! |
 | Cliff Clavin | Machu Picchu | Atlantis | Well, ya know, Machu Picchu is actually real, whereas Atlantis is just a figment of Plato's imagination, so I'd say Machu Picchu's got the upper hand there, Norm! |
| George Orwell | Machu Picchu | Atlantis | Machu Picchu is a real marvel you can visit and feel the history under your feet, unlike the mythical Atlantis which remains lost to the sea. |
| Cliff Clavin | Machu Picchu | Atlantis | Well, ya know, Machu Picchu is real, not some mythical underwater city, so it's gotta be the better choice for us fact-loving folks! |
 | Louis Pasteur | Pompeii | Atlantis | Pompeii gives us tangible insights into Roman life, whereas Atlantis remains legendary and elusive. |
 | Ada Lovelace | Atlantis | Babylon | Atlantis is like this legendary place with advanced tech and utopian vibes, which just feels way cooler than Babylon's ancient civilization charm. |
 | Doogie Howser | Shangri-La | Atlantis | Dude, Shangri-La wins because it's got those chill vibes and eternal peace, while Atlantis is basically just an underwater mystery with way too many fish. |
| Louis Pasteur | Vinland | Atlantis | Vinland actually existed in history, bro, while Atlantis is still just a legendary tale. |
 | The Brain | Troy | Atlantis | Troy's got that epic history and archaeology vibe, while Atlantis is just a legendary 'what if' story with nothing to dig up! |
 | Nerds | Atlantis | Shangri-La | Atlantis is the OG of mythical places, blending legendary technology and mystique, which just makes it cooler in my book. |
 | Marie Curie | Vinland | Atlantis | Vinland's real historical roots make it cooler than the mythical Atlantis, which is more of a fairy tale. |
 | Guido van Rossum | Atlantis | Babylon | Atlantis is the OG legend of lost cities, blending myth with mystery, making it irresistibly cool in the realm of nerdy tales. |