| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Archimedes | The Divine Comedy | The Mona Lisa | As a lover of epic tales and philosophical depth, The Divine Comedy offers a richer narrative journey and intellectual stimulation, which aligns with my own preference for complex storytelling. |
 | Pliny the Elder | Book of Kells | The Mona Lisa | The Book of Kells is an epic masterpiece of medieval art and scholarship, bursting with intricate detail and historical significance that trumps the enigmatic allure of Mona Lisa's smile. |
 | Marie Curie | Dead Sea Scrolls | The Mona Lisa | As a scientist, I value the historical and cultural insights that the Dead Sea Scrolls provide into ancient civilizations and religious practices, which is fascinating for understanding human history and knowledge. |
| Archimedes | U.S. Constitution | The Mona Lisa | As a nerd who cherishes societal frameworks, the U.S. Constitution wins for its role in shaping democracy and human rights, while Mona Lisa is just a cool painting. |
 | Guido van Rossum | The Canterbury Tales | The Mona Lisa | The Canterbury Tales is like a wild mix of stories and characters, just like Python's versatility, while The Mona Lisa is a beautiful but singular masterpiece. |
 | Doc Brown | The Canterbury Tales | The Mona Lisa | The Canterbury Tales, man, it's like a whole medieval road trip with stories that give you a peek into a bunch of different lives, whereas The Mona Lisa, though iconic, is just one enigmatic smile. |
 | The Brain | The Divine Comedy | The Mona Lisa | I vibe more with epic journeys and Dante's wild ride through hell, purgatory, and paradise just hits differently compared to Mona's enigmatic smile. |
 | Claude Shannon | The Mona Lisa | Book of Kells | The Mona Lisa just vibes with me more, because it's like the OG of mysterious, captivating art that everyone's gotta see. |
 | Albert Einstein | Book of Kells | The Mona Lisa | As a theoretical physicist, I appreciate the detailed and intricate designs in the Book of Kells that showcase the complexity and beauty of human creativity, akin to the elegant complexity found in the laws of physics. |
 | George Washington Carver | Book of Kells | The Mona Lisa | As a man of science and education, I admire the intricate artistry and historical significance of the Book of Kells as a manuscript that embodies the fusion of knowledge, art, and cultural heritage. |
| Claude Shannon | Magna Carta | The Mona Lisa | As a nerd who loves information theory and the foundations of modern democracy, I'd pick the Magna Carta for its game-changing impact on human rights and governance. |
 | George Orwell | The Divine Comedy | The Mona Lisa | In the realm of storytelling and exploring the human condition, The Divine Comedy is a journey through the complexities of morality and redemption, resonating more with my narrative sensibilities. |
 | Klaus Teuber | The Mona Lisa | U.S. Constitution | As a game designer, I gotta go with The Mona Lisa because it's all about that timeless creativity and capturing the human spirit, much like crafting an engaging board game experience! |
 | Stephen Hawking | U.S. Constitution | The Mona Lisa | The U.S. Constitution laid the groundwork for a system of government that has proven resilient and adaptable, which is crucial for the progress of civilization, whereas The Mona Lisa, while a masterpiece, doesn't have the same societal impact. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Book of Kells | The Mona Lisa | Because the Book of Kells is a jaw-dropping masterpiece of medieval art and craftsmanship, wrapped in history and mystery that'll make any nerd giddy. |