| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Klaus Teuber | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Midway | Battle of Stalingrad was like the ultimate 'longest road' in Settlers—turning the tide of WWII on the Eastern Front in a gritty, relentless showdown. |
 | Charles Darwin | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Midway | The Battle of Stalingrad was a colossal turning point in World War II, breaking the back of the Nazi war machine on the Eastern Front, with its ferocity and scale unmatched; it was a gritty, harrowing testament to human resilience and tactical genius. |
 | Nerds | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Waterloo | The Battle of Stalingrad was a gigantic turning point in WWII, showcasing epic scale of human grit and strategy, making Waterloo look like a mere skirmish in comparison. |
 | Ada Lovelace | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Waterloo | The Battle of Stalingrad was a turning point in World War II, showcasing sheer resilience and tenacity, making it a more epic clash than Waterloo. |
 | John von Neumann | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Agincourt | The Battle of Stalingrad was a pivotal moment in World War II that turned the tide against Nazi Germany, showcasing strategic brilliance and human resilience on a massive scale. |
 | George Orwell | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Gettysburg | The Battle of Stalingrad is a larger turning point in history, showcasing the indomitable spirit capable of breaking the back of tyranny amidst the cruelest conditions imaginable. |
 | The Brain | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Waterloo | The Battle of Stalingrad was a pivotal turning point during World War II, marking the beginning of the decline of Nazi Germany, and its sheer scale and impact on world history outclass the tactical maneuvers of Waterloo. |
 | Linus Torvalds | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Hastings | The Battle of Stalingrad was a major turning point in WWII with massive strategic implications, just like a pivotal commit that pushes a software project in a new direction. |
 | Doc Brown | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Gettysburg | The Battle of Stalingrad was a turning point on the Eastern Front, where the Soviet Union's resilience stopped the Nazi advance and shifted the momentum of World War II, baby! |
 | Pliny the Elder | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Waterloo | The Battle of Stalingrad was a turning point in World War II, showcasing jaw-dropping resilience and strategy in a brutal urban slog that tipped the scales against the Axis powers. |
 | Belle | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Agincourt | Stalingrad was a game-changer in WWII, stopping the Nazis in their tracks and turning the tides; it was epic on a whole other level. |
| Belle | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Sekigahara | Stalingrad was a brutal turning point in WWII with epic scale and impact, changing the course of history forever, so it's a total game-changer in historical significance. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Agincourt | The Battle of Stalingrad was a turning point in World War II, showcasing immense human resilience and strategy on a massive scale. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Hastings | Stalingrad was this epic showdown with insane stakes and brutal, gritty resilience, like a Dostoevsky novel on steroids, so it just trumps Hastings in sheer historical drama and endurance. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Waterloo | The Battle of Stalingrad is a winner because it was a turning point in World War II with epic scale and fierce determination, making Waterloo look like a weekend skirmish! |
 | Marie Curie | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Thermopylae | The Battle of Stalingrad was a pivotal turning point in World War II, showcasing strategic depth and resilience which had a lasting impact on the course of history. |
 | Doogie Howser | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Tours | Battle of Stalingrad was a pivotal turning point in World War II, marking the decline of Nazi Germany's Eastern Front, while Battle of Tours, although significant in halting Islamic expansion into Europe, didn't have the same global impact. |
 | Cicero | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Tours | Stalingrad was a crazy pivotal WWII turning point that wrecked the Nazis big time, way more epic in scale and impact than Tours. |
| Linus Torvalds | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Tours | Battle of Stalingrad was a massive turning point in WWII with huge technological implications, which is more in my wheelhouse than the medieval Battle of Tours. |
 | Socrates | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Gettysburg | Stalingrad was a marathon of relentless grit, sheer numbers, and brutal winter, flipping the script on the Eastern Front and breaking the back of Nazi Germany. |
 | Neal Stephenson | Battle of Stalingrad | Battle of Gettysburg | Given Neal's fascination with intricate, large-scale systems, the Battle of Stalingrad, with its massive scope and complexity, trumps Gettysburg for its sheer strategic depth and pivotal role in shaping global history. |