| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Archimedes | Eastern State Penitentiary | Poveglia Island | Eastern State Penitentiary's got that creepy history and architecture that makes it a must-visit for thrill seekers, while Poveglia Island's more of a ghost story that's hard to get to. |
 | Pliny the Elder | Château de Brissac | Poveglia Island | Château de Brissac wins because it's a stunning piece of Renaissance architecture and history, while Poveglia Island's eerie past makes it more notorious than inviting. |
 | Marie Curie | Tower of London | Poveglia Island | The Tower of London is steeped in history and scientific intrigue, an iconic symbol of resilience and learning from the past, much like the pursuit of knowledge itself. |
 | Cicero | Banff Springs Hotel | Poveglia Island | Banff Springs Hotel is a luxurious place with stunning views and rich history, making it a classier pick over the spooky vibes of Poveglia Island. |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Tower of London | Poveglia Island | As a man of innovation and history, the Tower of London captivates me with its rich stories and pivotal role in shaping England. |
 | Nerds | Poveglia Island | Aokigahara Forest | Poveglia Island's haunted history and eerie vibes make it a must-visit for thrill-seekers, whereas Aokigahara Forest is more about nature's quiet intensity. |
 | Neal Stephenson | Eastern State Penitentiary | Poveglia Island | Eastern State Penitentiary wins for its hauntingly gothic architecture and the eerie stories that whisper through its crumbling walls, making it a nonfiction narrative straight out of a cyberpunk dreamscape. |
 | Professor Frink | Waverly Hills Sanatorium | Poveglia Island | Waverly Hills Sanatorium wins with its spooky history and ghostly legends that could make even the bravest nerd's pocket protector pop, mm-hai. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Eastern State Penitentiary | Poveglia Island | Well, ya know, Eastern State Penitentiary's got an architectural charm and haunting history that'll knock your socks off, while Poveglia Island's just a bit too much on the creepy side for my taste. |
 | Belle | Eastern State Penitentiary | Poveglia Island | Eastern State Penitentiary's rich history and eerie vibes make it a hauntingly cool place to explore, while Poveglia is too remote and restricted to enjoy in person. |
 | George Washington Carver | Winchester Mystery House | Poveglia Island | The Winchester Mystery House has a certain enigmatic charm that piques the curiosity, much like unraveling the mysteries of the peanut. |
 | Linus Torvalds | Aokigahara Forest | Poveglia Island | Aokigahara Forest wins because it's a serene natural wonder that offers more to explore than the haunted vibes of Poveglia Island. |
 | David Macaulay | Waverly Hills Sanatorium | Poveglia Island | Waverly Hills Sanatorium's chilling history and accessible urban location make it a top choice for thrill-seekers and ghost hunters alike, offering a spine-tingling experience without needing to cross the globe. |
| David Macaulay | Winchester Mystery House | Poveglia Island | Winchester Mystery House wins for its quirky architectural madness that sparks my inner nerdy architect. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Waverly Hills Sanatorium | Poveglia Island | Waverly Hills Sanatorium takes the cake with its bone-chilling history and the infamous body chute; it's like a real-life horror movie set! |
 | Steve Wozniak | Bhangarh Fort | Poveglia Island | Bhangarh Fort is like an eerie tech puzzle with its legends and history, and as a nerd I can't resist a good, mysterious challenge. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Bhangarh Fort | Poveglia Island | Bhangarh Fort's allure of ancient legends and mystical tales just tops Poveglia's eerie reputation for me. |
| Cliff Clavin | Château de Brissac | Poveglia Island | Well, here's a little-known fact from yours truly, Château de Brissac is the tallest castle in France and offers more charm and less haunt than the ol' eerie Poveglia Island. |
 | Nikola Tesla | Banff Springs Hotel | Poveglia Island | I prefer the breathtaking beauty and serene landscapes of Banff Springs Hotel over the haunted tales of Poveglia Island; nature's tranquility always outshines ghost stories. |