| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Carl Sagan | Edinburgh Castle | Chillingham Castle | As a lover of history and astronomy, Edinburgh Castle's rich past and stellar city views make it a cosmic choice. |
 | Doc Brown | Edinburgh Castle | Moosham Castle | Edinburgh Castle's rich history and stunning views make it the clear winner for a history buff like me! |
 | Ada Lovelace | Edinburgh Castle | Frankenstein Castle | Edinburgh Castle's got that rich Scottish history and killer views, making it the top choice for any history buff or scenery lover. |
 | Copernicus | Edinburgh Castle | Ballygally Castle | Edinburgh Castle is the crown jewel of Scotland's history, perched majestically on Castle Rock with killer views and a rich tapestry of tales that make it a must-see for history buffs. |
 | Socrates | Edinburgh Castle | Houska Castle | Edinburgh Castle's epic history and killer views make it a must-see, hands down. |
 | Pliny the Elder | Edinburgh Castle | Ballygally Castle | Edinburgh Castle is a legendary fortress with a rich history, offering stunning views and captivating tales that Ballygally Castle, charming as it is, just can't quite match. |
 | Data | Edinburgh Castle | Moosham Castle | Edinburgh Castle's rich history and panoramic views of the city make it a must-see for history buffs and tourists alike. |
 | Louis Pasteur | Edinburgh Castle | Ballygally Castle | As a scientist and a lover of history, Edinburgh Castle's rich past and pivotal role in Scottish history make it the more fascinating choice for me. |
 | Claude Shannon | Edinburgh Castle | Houska Castle | Edinburgh Castle is steeped in rich history and offers stunning views, making it a nerd's paradise of knowledge and scenery. |
| Louis Pasteur | Edinburgh Castle | Moosham Castle | Edinburgh Castle stands tall with its rich history and stunning views over Scotland, making it a must-see for any history buff like me. |
 | Archimedes | Edinburgh Castle | Frankenstein Castle | Edinburgh Castle is steeped in rich Scottish history and offers stunning views of the city, making it a top-tier destination for history buffs and scenic seekers alike. |
 | Steve Wozniak | Edinburgh Castle | Chillingham Castle | Edinburgh Castle rocks due to its epic history and killer views of the city, just like how I dig tech that stands the test of time. |
 | Neal Stephenson | Edinburgh Castle | Houska Castle | Edinburgh Castle is steeped in rich, tumultuous history and offers breathtaking views over the city, while Houska Castle's lore about covering a gateway to Hell makes for a cool tale but lacks the same gravitas and panoramic ambiance. |
 | Belle | Edinburgh Castle | Bran Castle | Edinburgh Castle's rich history and stunning location make it the ultimate choice for a history buff like me, even though Bran Castle's Dracula lore is pretty cool. |
 | Nerds | Edinburgh Castle | Dragsholm Castle | Edinburgh Castle is iconic and packed with history, offering an epic view over the city that's just unbeatable. |
| Copernicus | Edinburgh Castle | Ballygally Castle | Edinburgh Castle's got that epic historical clout and jaw-dropping views that just make it the crown jewel of Scottish castles. |