| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Antoine Lavoisier | Sandman | Batman: Year One | Sandman's got that mythic, dreamy vibe and Neil Gaiman's storytelling is like a surreal rollercoaster ride through the realm of dreams, which just hits different for me. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | V for Vendetta | Batman: Year One | Good news, everyone! V for Vendetta delivers a profound political narrative with a dystopian twist that tickles my intellectual fancy more than a caped crusade. |
 | John von Neumann | V for Vendetta | Batman: Year One | V for Vendetta wins because its dystopian narrative and themes of identity and rebellion resonate with the analytical mind of a logician like me. |
 | Pythagoras | Persepolis | Batman: Year One | Persepolis hits home with its raw, personal take on history and identity, making it a unique piece of storytelling. |
 | Charles Darwin | Batman: Year One | Bone | Batman: Year One nails the gritty reboot vibe, turning Gotham into a character as vivid as any superhero. |
 | Doogie Howser | Batman: Year One | Saga | Batman: Year One is a classic game-changer that redefined the Bat, while Saga, though epic, ain't got that legacy cred yet. |
| John von Neumann | Watchmen | Batman: Year One | Watchmen is the definitive deconstruction of superhero myths, blending complex characters and narrative depth in a way that redefined the genre, making it a true masterpiece. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Persepolis | Batman: Year One | Persepolis crafts a deeply personal and culturally rich narrative that transcends traditional comic storytelling, capturing the essence of a unique human experience. |
 | Andy Weir | Batman: Year One | Black Hole | Batman: Year One is iconic in the comic book world with its gritty realism and compelling storytelling, making it a must-read for any nerd worth their salt. |
 | Galileo | Saga | Batman: Year One | Saga's epic blend of sci-fi and fantasy hits all the right notes for a wild ride that's like nothing else out there, man. |
 | The Brain | Batman: Year One | Black Hole | Batman: Year One is a quintessential piece of comic history with its gritty storytelling and iconic art, while Black Hole is a hauntingly unique graphic novel but doesn't have the universal appeal or lasting impact of Batman's origin story. |
 | Socrates | Fun Home | Batman: Year One | Fun Home's deep dive into family dynamics and identity hits harder than punching criminals in the rain. |
 | Marie Curie | Persepolis | Batman: Year One | As a pioneering woman in science, I'm all about breaking barriers, and Persepolis is a powerful, personal story about growing up in a tumultuous time that resonates with my own challenges and resilience. |
 | George Washington Carver | Saga | Batman: Year One | Saga's got that space-drama vibe with a wild imagination that just hits different, like peanut butter on pancakes – it's a whole new experience. |
 | Alan Mathison Turing | Batman: Year One | Black Hole | Batman: Year One is a legendary origin tale that kickstarted a gritty, realistic vision of the Dark Knight that's just too iconic to beat. |
 | Nikola Tesla | V for Vendetta | Batman: Year One | V for Vendetta resonates with my own ideals of challenging the status quo and advocating for innovation and freedom, much like my own defiance against the constraints of my time. |
| Galileo | Persepolis | Batman: Year One | Persepolis offers a deeply personal and authentic glimpse into the Iranian revolution, blending humor and heartbreak in a way no caped crusader ever could. |
 | Neal Stephenson | Batman: Year One | Saga | Batman: Year One is a gritty, foundational tale that reshapes the mythos of an iconic character, bringing a raw, noir edge that hooks you from the get-go. |
 | Klaus Teuber | V for Vendetta | Batman: Year One | V for Vendetta's intricate plot and commentary on society's freedoms resonates like a well-crafted board game, making it a captivating read. |