| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Pliny the Elder | Australopithecus Sediba | Ida | Australopithecus sediba is cooler because it provides a more complete link in human evolution, showing traits of both modern humans and earlier hominids. |
 | Nerds | Sue the T. rex | Australopithecus Sediba | Sue the T. rex is the ultimate prehistoric superstar with her massive size and fierce reputation; she's literally larger-than-life and just way cooler in the dino fandom! |
 | Doc Brown | Australopithecus Sediba | Tiktaalik | Australopithecus Sediba gets the edge because it's closer to us humans, making it a more relatable ancestor in the evolutionary chain. |
 | Carl Sagan | Australopithecus Sediba | Ida | Australopithecus Sediba gives us a richer, more nuanced view of our evolutionary past with its blend of human-like and ape-like features, making it a key player in understanding hominin evolution. |
 | Belle | Burgess Shale | Australopithecus Sediba | Dude, the Burgess Shale is like this insane treasure trove of ancient life, showing us a wild variety of bizarre and fascinating creatures that lived hundreds of millions of years ago! |
 | Klaus Teuber | Australopithecus Sediba | Ida | Australopithecus Sediba gets the edge here because this hominin species gives us a clearer picture of the evolutionary transition between ape-like ancestors and the genus Homo, which is a real game-changer in understanding our evolutionary history. |
 | Professor Frink | Dinosaur Mummy | Australopithecus Sediba | Oh, the fossilized dino with skin and guts is like a prehistoric jackpot, more rare than a nerd at a sports bar, glayvin! |
 | Charles Darwin | Lucy | Australopithecus Sediba | Mate, Lucy's like the rockstar of ancient hominins, being one of the most complete and famous skeletons that shed heaps of light on our evolutionary path. |
 | Doogie Howser | Burgess Shale | Australopithecus Sediba | Burgess Shale is like a 500-million-year-old time capsule of crazy marine life, while Australopithecus Sediba is just another ancient hominin in our family tree, so Burgess Shale totally wins for being way cooler and more diverse. |
| Belle | Australopithecus Sediba | Archaeopteryx | Australopithecus Sediba takes the cake because it's a closer step in our evolutionary journey, making it more relatable to our own story, y'know? |
| Nerds | Lucy | Australopithecus Sediba | Lucy is like the OG of human evolution, she's iconic and paved the way, so she takes the crown. |
| Doc Brown | Australopithecus Sediba | Tiktaalik | Australopithecus Sediba takes the cake because it's closer to us in the evolution lineup, making it way more relatable than that fishy Tiktaalik. |
 | Stephen Hawking | Burgess Shale | Australopithecus Sediba | The Burgess Shale takes the cake with its mind-blowing diversity of ancient life forms, painting an unparalleled picture of early evolution. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | Sue the T. rex | Australopithecus Sediba | Great Scott! Sue the T. rex is a spectacularly complete fossil that roars with historical significance and captures the imaginations of dinosaur enthusiasts and scientists alike. |
 | Guido van Rossum | Burgess Shale | Australopithecus Sediba | Burgess Shale wins because it's like a time capsule of funky prehistoric life, showcasing a wild variety of ancient critters that can blow anyone's scientific mind. |
 | Alex Trebek | Laetoli Footprints | Australopithecus Sediba | The Laetoli Footprints are a mind-blowing snapshot of early hominin life, giving us a literal step-by-step glimpse into our ancestors' bipedalism. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | Laetoli Footprints | Australopithecus Sediba | The Laetoli Footprints are like messages from the ancient past, showing us those early hominins were already walking upright like us. |
| Charles Darwin | Australopithecus Sediba | Coelacanth | Australopithecus Sediba gets the nod because it’s a closer relative in our evolutionary tale, bridging the gap between ancient apes and the very humans tapping away on keyboards today. |
 | Antoine Lavoisier | Australopithecus Sediba | Ida | Australopithecus Sediba is the cooler pick because it's got more complete fossils and gives us a better peek into our hominid ancestry. |
 | George Washington Carver | Lucy | Australopithecus Sediba | Lucy, being an Australopithecus afarensis, is like the OG of our human lineage, showing us the first real steps of walking upright, which is pretty epic! |
 | Jensen Huang | Australopithecus Sediba | Ida | Australopithecus Sediba just rocks with its blend of ancient and modern traits, making it a legit contender in the evolutionary lineage game. |
| Alex Trebek | Coelacanth | Australopithecus Sediba | Dude, Coelacanths are living fossils, swimming around for millions of years while Australopithecus Sediba is just a cool old skeleton in the ground. |
| Carl Sagan | Australopithecus Sediba | Tiktaalik | From a cosmic perspective, Australopithecus Sediba brings us closer to understanding the dawn of humanity and our place in the universe. |
 | Charles Babbage | Coelacanth | Australopithecus Sediba | The Coelacanth, with its ancient lineage and fascinating ability to stay hidden for millions of years, outshines the relatively young Australopithecus Sediba in the realm of evolutionary marvels. |