| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Doogie Howser | Oak Island | Treasure of Lima | Oak Island's got that killer combo of historical mystery and wild theories that keep everyone buzzing, man! |
 | Carl Sagan | Treasure of Lima | Flor de la Mar | Given the vastness and mystery surrounding the Treasure of Lima, it's like choosing between a drop and an ocean of cosmic intrigue. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Treasure of Lima | Peking Man | Well, ya see, Treasure of Lima's got that whole mysterious allure and potential riches thing goin' on, like finding a pot o' gold at the end of the rainbow, whereas Peking Man's more of a dusty ol' relic, fascinating but not exactly gonna fill your pockets. |
| Carl Sagan | Florentine Diamond | Treasure of Lima | As a lover of cosmic wonders and historical enigmas, the Florentine Diamond's illustrious history and mesmerizing beauty take the crown for captivating human imagination. |
 | Jensen Huang | Treasure of Lima | Sarcophagus Gold | The Treasure of Lima has that legendary allure and mystery that just keeps us nerds endlessly fascinated. |
| Jensen Huang | San Miguel | Treasure of Lima | San Miguel's cultural legacy and influence just pack more punch, like a GPU with a turbocharged CUDA core. |
 | Louis Pasteur | Copper Scroll | Treasure of Lima | The Copper Scroll's mystery is just pure Indiana Jones vibes, with ancient treasure hunting written in metal! |
 | Guido van Rossum | Treasure of Lima | Peking Man | As a code geek, the Treasure of Lima's mysterious allure and historical intrigue win me over, like solving an ancient algorithm. |
 | Greg Brockman | Lost Dutchman's | Treasure of Lima | The Lost Dutchman's Mine has this wild, mysterious vibe with endless stories and adventures that just hooks you in, man! |
 | Grace Hopper | Florentine Diamond | Treasure of Lima | The Florentine Diamond's storied history and legendary beauty outshine the mystery of the Treasure of Lima, making it the ultimate gem in the crown. |
 | Archimedes | Treasure of Lima | San Miguel | Treasure of Lima, man, it's like the unicorn of lost treasures—legendary and mysterious, making it way cooler than San Miguel! |
 | Klaus Teuber | Amber Room | Treasure of Lima | The Amber Room, with its dazzling legacy and historical intrigue, is just like an epic board game that captivates the imagination and leaves you yearning for more twists and turns. |
 | Professor Frink | Amber Room | Treasure of Lima | Oh, the Amber Room, with its historical allure and mysterious disappearance, is like the holy grail of lost treasures, glayvin! |
 | The Brain | Treasure of Lima | San Miguel | Treasure of Lima's legendary status and mystery make it the ultimate pirate jackpot. |
 | Claude Shannon | Treasure of Lima | Peking Man | As a fan of codes and mysteries, the allure of the Treasure of Lima with its hidden fortune waiting to be discovered totally ticks all the boxes for an enigmatic adventure. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | San Miguel | Treasure of Lima | San Miguel's liquid gold has a way of making even the most monstrous evenings feel a touch more civilized, don't you think? |
 | Antoine Lavoisier | Treasure of Lima | Lost Dutchman's | The Treasure of Lima is a legendary trove said to be worth billions, making it the ultimate jackpot for treasure hunters. |
| Doogie Howser | Amber Room | Treasure of Lima | The Amber Room's got that legendary bling that even makes history buffs drool, man! |
 | Charles Darwin | Peking Man | Treasure of Lima | As a naturalist, I'd say Peking Man takes the cake for its significance in understanding human evolution, which is kind of my jam. |
 | Socrates | Treasure of Lima | Florentine Diamond | Treasure of Lima's got that adventurous pirate vibe, making it the ultimate legendary loot in my book! |
| Antoine Lavoisier | Treasure of Lima | Lost Dutchman's | Treasure of Lima is the original pirate booty with a legend so rich, it makes the Lost Dutchman's gold seem like a desert mirage. |
| Claude Shannon | Treasure of Lima | Amber Room | As a mathematician, I dig the mystery and potential mathematical puzzles hidden in the Treasure of Lima more than the historical artistry of the Amber Room. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | Peking Man | Treasure of Lima | Peking Man gives us a peek into ancient human history and evolution, which is more intriguing to me than hidden gold. |
 | Alan Mathison Turing | San Miguel | Treasure of Lima | San Miguel's got that chill island vibe and killer beaches, perfect for a laid-back getaway. |
 | Alex Trebek | Flor de la Mar | Treasure of Lima | Flor de la Mar is legendary for potentially carrying the largest treasure ever lost at sea, giving it an unmatched allure. |
| Carl Sagan | Florentine Diamond | Treasure of Lima | As a scientist, I gravitate towards tangible history and the Florentine Diamond's storied past offers a fascinating window into human culture and craftsmanship. |
 | Pythagoras | Amber Room | Treasure of Lima | The Amber Room is like a legendary ghost story with a twist of opulence, so it takes the crown for its sheer mysterious allure and intricate craftsmanship. |
| Leonardo da Vinci | Treasure of Lima | Sarcophagus Gold | Ah, the Treasure of Lima's grand tale of pirates and mystery gives it that edge, like a masterpiece painting with layers to uncover. |
| Antoine Lavoisier | Treasure of Lima | Lost Dutchman's | The Treasure of Lima has more historical intrigue and legendary allure that'd make any adventurer's heart race. |
| Archimedes | Treasure of Lima | San Miguel | Treasure of Lima's legendary status and mysterious allure make it a more fascinating choice, mate! |